All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Pre-stressed concrete is more desirable in case of

The correct answer is

Cylindrical pipes subjected to internal fluid pressure

Pre-stressed Concrete Applications in Pipes

Pre-stressed concrete is a type of concrete where internal stresses are introduced deliberately to counteract the tensile stresses that occur when the structure is subjected to external loads. This technique significantly improves the strength, durability, and load-bearing capacity of concrete structures, especially those subjected to tensile forces.

Analyzing Stresses in Cylindrical Pipes

Cylindrical pipes are commonly used to transport fluids under pressure. The pressure exerts forces on the pipe walls, inducing stresses. Let's analyze the stresses caused by different conditions:

  • Internal Fluid Pressure: When fluid is contained within a pipe under pressure ($p$), it tends to push the pipe walls outwards. This generates tensile stresses, primarily circumferential (hoop stress, $\sigma_h$) and longitudinal stress ($\sigma_l$). The hoop stress is typically the critical one, calculated approximately as $\sigma_h = \frac{p \times r}{t}$, where $r$ is the inner radius and $t$ is the wall thickness. This tensile stress can lead to cracking if not managed.
  • External Fluid Pressure: Conversely, external pressure tends to crush the pipe inwards, inducing compressive stresses in the walls.
  • Equal Internal and External Pressures: The net effect depends on the difference between internal and external pressures. If they are equal, the net pressure is zero, and stresses are minimal.
  • End Pressures: Pressures acting on the ends of the pipe primarily cause longitudinal stresses.

Why Pre-stressed Concrete is Ideal for Internal Pressure

Pre-stressed concrete is most beneficial when the structure is subjected to significant tensile stresses. In the case of cylindrical pipes:

  • Internal fluid pressure creates high tensile hoop stresses.
  • These tensile stresses are the primary cause of potential failure (cracking) in conventional concrete pipes.
  • By applying pre-stressing (usually through high-strength steel tendons), a permanent state of compression is introduced into the concrete pipe wall.
  • This initial compression directly counteracts the tensile stresses induced by the internal fluid pressure.
  • Even when the pipe is under internal pressure, the resultant stress in the concrete may remain compressive or at least significantly reduced tension, preventing cracking and enhancing the pipe's lifespan and safety.

For pipes subjected mainly to external pressure, the induced stresses are compressive. While pre-stressing can still be applied, its advantage in preventing tensile failure is less pronounced compared to situations with high internal pressure.

Conclusion

Given that internal fluid pressure generates critical tensile hoop stresses in cylindrical pipes, pre-stressed concrete is highly desirable in this scenario. The pre-compression effectively manages these tensile stresses, making it a superior choice for applications like water mains, penstocks, and other pressure conduits.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Analysis of Prestress

  1. The suitability of post tensioning is good for:

  2. As per IS:1343-2012, the minimum characteristic strength of pre-stressed concrete to be used for post-tensioned and pre-tensioned structural elements are respectively:

  3. Which of the following is a disadvantage in the case of Freyssinet system of post tensioning?

  4. Which of the following post tensioning system adopts metallic sandwich plates, flat wedges and distribution plate for anchoring the wires?

  5. The upward deflection of a pre-stressed beam with a straight tendon at a uniform eccentricity below the centroidal axis is given by ______, where P - effective pre-stressing force, e - eccentricity, L - length of the beam, E - Modulus of elasticity, I - moment of inertia:

Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App