Question
Match the LIST-I with LIST-II
List – I Case Law List – II Concept A Ashby v/s White II Violation of absolute right B Rylands v/s Fletcher III Strict liability C Olga Tellis v/s Bombay Municipal Corp. I Poverty as an involuntary act under Tort D Allen v/s Flood IV Motive is irrelevant in Tort
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
The correct answer is
A-II, B-III, C-I, D-IV
Case Law Matching Explanation
This question requires matching specific legal case laws from List-I with the legal concepts they represent in List-II.
Analyzing the Matches
- Ashby v/s White: This landmark case established that a legal right invaded grants a cause of action even without proof of damage. This corresponds to the concept of Violation of absolute right. (A-II)
- Rylands v/s Fletcher: This case is foundational for the tort of negligence, particularly concerning the rule of Strict liability for damage caused by something escaping from one's property. (B-III)
- Olga Tellis v/s Bombay Municipal Corp.: Often referred to as the Pavement Dwellers case, it significantly addressed the right to life and livelihood, linking basic survival needs and the impact of poverty on fundamental rights. This aligns with Poverty as an involuntary act under Tort. (C-I)
- Allen v/s Flood: This case determined that causing loss to another through lawful means, even with malicious intent, does not create liability. It implies that Motive is irrelevant in Tort if the act itself is not unlawful. (D-IV)
Summary of Matches
| List-I Case Law | List-II Concept |
|---|---|
| A. Ashby v/s White | II. Violation of absolute right |
| B. Rylands v/s Fletcher | III. Strict liability |
| C. Olga Tellis v/s Bombay Municipal Corp. | I. Poverty as an involuntary act under Tort |
| D. Allen v/s Flood | IV. Motive is irrelevant in Tort |
The correct matching, derived from the analysis, is A-II, B-III, C-I, and D-IV.
Was this answer helpful?
Important Questions from Law of Torts and Consumer Protection
- A philosophy of punishments that aims to prevent criminal activity through the development and application of effective sanctions is called:
- Only a proportion of crimes committed find their way into Criminal Justice Process, is called:
- Match LIST-I with LIST-II
LIST-I LIST-II A. Hedonism II. In Pursuit of Pleasure B. Hidden Crime I. Crimes not Recorded in Official Crime
DataC. Incapacitation IV. Removal of Offenders' Ability to
Commit CrimeD. Incarceration III. The Process of Confining or Segregating
Offending Populations
Choose the correct answer from the options given below: - Which of the following case decided by the Supreme Court of India deals with the concept of 'Public Wrong'
under Tort? - Match the LIST-I with LIST-II
LIST-I
(Theory)LIST-II
(Propounder)A. Pigeon Hole Theory I. William Prosser B. Neighbour Rule II. Wenfield C. Tort is Social Engineering III. Lord Atkin D. Use of phrase 'Law of Tort' IV. Salmond
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Need Expert Advice?
