Which provision of Constitution provide power to parliament to establish a new state?
Article 2 & 3
Understanding Parliament's Power to Establish New States in India
The Constitution of India grants specific powers to the Parliament regarding the formation and alteration of states. Understanding these provisions is crucial for comprehending the territorial structure of the Indian Union.
Constitutional Provisions for State Formation
The primary articles that deal with the admission or establishment of new states and the alteration of the areas, boundaries, or names of existing states are found in Part I of the Constitution, which pertains to the Union and its Territory.
Let's examine the relevant articles:
- Article 2: Admission or establishment of new States: This article empowers the Parliament to admit into the Union, or establish, new States on such terms and conditions as it thinks fit. This provision primarily deals with the admission or establishment of states that were not part of India before, or areas acquired by India.
- Article 3: Formation of new States and alteration of areas, boundaries or names of existing States: This article empowers the Parliament to form a new State by separation of territory from any State or by uniting two or more States or parts of States or by uniting any territory to a part of any State; increase the area of any State; diminish the area of any State; alter the boundaries of any State; alter the name of any State. This provision deals with the reorganisation of the states already within the Indian Union.
- Article 4: Laws made under articles 2 and 3 to provide for the amendment of the First and the Fourth Schedules and supplemental, incidental and consequential matters: This article declares that any law made under Article 2 or Article 3 will contain provisions for the amendment of the First Schedule (listing the states and union territories) and the Fourth Schedule (allocating seats in the Council of States) to give effect to the provisions of the law. Furthermore, such a law shall not be deemed to be an amendment of the Constitution for the purposes of Article 368.
Analyzing the Question and Options
The question asks which provision provides power to Parliament to establish a new state. While Article 2 specifically mentions the "establishment of new States," Article 3 deals with the "formation of new States" by altering existing ones within the Union. Both articles provide Parliament with the power to create new states, albeit in different contexts (outside vs. inside the existing Union). Option 1 correctly identifies Article 2 & 3 together, reflecting the combined power of Parliament in creating new states, whether by admission, establishment from outside, or formation by altering existing states.
Conclusion
Therefore, the power to establish a new state or form a new state, encompassing both admitting territories and reorganizing existing ones, is primarily derived from Article 2 and Article 3 of the Constitution of India. Article 4 supports these actions by outlining the procedural consequences for the Schedules and clarifying that such laws are not constitutional amendments under Article 368.
| Article | Provision Summary | Relevance to New State Formation |
|---|---|---|
| Article 2 | Admission or establishment of new States. | Explicitly grants power to admit or establish new states (often from outside the Union). |
| Article 3 | Formation of new States and alteration of existing ones. | Grants power to form new states by altering the territories of existing states within the Union. |
| Article 4 | Laws under Articles 2 & 3 amend Schedules 1 & 4; not Article 368 amendments. | Supplements Articles 2 & 3 by detailing the procedural impact and nature of laws made under them. |
Revision Table: Key Articles for State Reorganisation
| Constitutional Article | Parliamentary Power |
|---|---|
| Article 2 | Admission into the Union or establishment of new States. |
| Article 3 | Formation of new States, alteration of areas, boundaries, or names of existing States. |
| Article 4 | Laws under Articles 2 & 3 amend Schedules I and IV and are not treated as constitutional amendments under Article 368. |
Additional Information: Process of State Formation
While Articles 2 and 3 grant the power, the process for forming a new state or altering an existing one is also outlined. For laws under Article 3, a Bill can only be introduced in Parliament on the recommendation of the President. Before recommending the Bill, the President has to refer it to the Legislature of the concerned State for expressing its views within a specified period. However, Parliament is not bound by the views of the State Legislature. This highlights the centralisation of power with the Union Parliament in matters of state reorganisation.
Laws made under Article 2 do not require prior reference to State Legislatures as they deal with territories not part of the existing states of the Union.
Both types of laws are passed by a simple majority in Parliament, reinforcing the provision in Article 4 that they are not amendments under Article 368, which requires a special majority.
Important Questions from Political Science
"Separate Electorate system" was introduced in which Act?
What is the significance of the civil rights movement in the USA that was carried on between 1954-1968?
What does BAMCEF stand for?
Which one of the is not the power of Parliament?
Which one of these is not a Pressure group ?
