All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Which one among the following oxides has the highest melting point?

The correct answer is MgO

Understanding the melting points of different oxides involves looking at the type of chemical bonding present and the strength of the forces holding the particles together in the solid state. Oxides can exhibit ionic, covalent, or a mixture of both types of bonding. Compounds with strong ionic bonding generally have high melting points because a large amount of energy is needed to overcome the strong electrostatic attractions between the oppositely charged ions in the crystal lattice.

Let's examine the given oxides:

  • Sodium Oxide (Na2O): Sodium is an alkali metal, and oxygen is a non-metal. The bond between sodium and oxygen is predominantly ionic. Sodium forms Na+ ions, and oxygen forms O2- ions. The electrostatic attraction is between Na+ and O2-.
  • Magnesium Oxide (MgO): Magnesium is an alkaline earth metal, and oxygen is a non-metal. The bond between magnesium and oxygen is also predominantly ionic. Magnesium forms Mg2+ ions, and oxygen forms O2- ions. The electrostatic attraction is between Mg2+ and O2-.
  • Iron(III) Oxide (Fe2O3): Iron is a transition metal, and oxygen is a non-metal. The bonding in transition metal oxides like Fe2O3 often has significant covalent character mixed with ionic bonding. Iron typically forms Fe3+ ions in this oxide. The attraction is between Fe3+ and O2-, but the partial covalent nature affects the overall lattice structure and bond strength compared to purely ionic compounds.
  • Copper(II) Oxide (CuO): Copper is also a transition metal. The bonding in CuO has a mixture of ionic and covalent character. Copper typically forms Cu2+ ions. The attraction is between Cu2+ and O2-.

Factors Influencing Melting Point in Ionic Compounds

For predominantly ionic compounds, the melting point is strongly related to the lattice energy. Lattice energy is the energy required to break apart one mole of an ionic solid into its gaseous ions. Higher lattice energy means stronger forces and a higher melting point. Lattice energy is influenced by:

  • Charge of the ions: Higher charges on the ions lead to stronger electrostatic attraction and higher lattice energy. The lattice energy is proportional to the product of the charges (q1 * q2).
  • Size of the ions: Smaller ionic radii lead to a shorter distance between the ion centers, resulting in stronger electrostatic attraction and higher lattice energy. The lattice energy is inversely proportional to the distance between the ion centers (r0).

The formula for lattice energy (Born-Lande equation, simplified) is approximately proportional to $\frac{|q_1 q_2|}{r_0}$.

Comparing the Oxides' Melting Points

Let's compare the relevant factors for the given oxides:

Oxide Ions Ion Charges Relative Ion Sizes Bonding Type Approximate Lattice Energy (Qualitative) Approximate Melting Point (°C)
Na2O Na+, O2- +1, -2 Na+ > Mg2+ Mostly Ionic Medium (low charges) ~1132
MgO Mg2+, O2- +2, -2 Mg2+ < Na+ Mostly Ionic Very High (high charges, relatively small ions) ~2852
Fe2O3 Fe3+, O2- +3, -2 Fe3+ < Mg2+ (size varies with state) Ionic/Covalent High (high charges, but complex structure due to covalent character) ~1594
CuO Cu2+, O2- +2, -2 Cu2+ ~ Mg2+ (size varies) Ionic/Covalent Medium/High (complex structure, lower charges than Fe2O3) ~1326 (decomposes)

Comparing MgO and Na2O, MgO has significantly higher ion charges (+2, -2) compared to Na2O (+1, -2). Also, the Mg2+ ion is smaller than the Na+ ion. Both factors contribute to a much higher lattice energy for MgO than for Na2O. This explains why MgO has a much higher melting point than Na2O.

Comparing MgO with Fe2O3 and CuO is less straightforward because these oxides have significant covalent character, which means the bonding isn't purely based on simple ionic attraction in a perfect lattice. However, considering the extremely strong electrostatic attraction in MgO due to the high +2 and -2 charges and relatively small ions forming a very stable rock-salt structure, MgO possesses an exceptionally high lattice energy among simple metal oxides. While Fe3+ has a higher charge (+3), the bonding is not purely ionic, and the structure is more complex (like corundum structure for α-Fe2O3), leading to a lower melting point than MgO.

Magnesium oxide (MgO) has a very high melting point (around 2852 °C) due to its strong ionic bonding, resulting from the high charges (+2 and -2) and relatively small sizes of the Mg2+ and O2- ions, leading to a very high lattice energy.

Conclusion

Based on the strength of ionic bonding, primarily determined by ion charges and sizes, MgO has the highest lattice energy among the given options. This results in MgO having the highest melting point.

Revision Table: Properties of Selected Oxides

Oxide Formula Bonding Nature Key Factors for High Melting Point
Sodium Oxide Na2O Ionic Lower ion charges (+1, -2) limit lattice energy.
Magnesium Oxide MgO Ionic High ion charges (+2, -2) and small ion sizes lead to very high lattice energy.
Iron(III) Oxide Fe2O3 Ionic/Covalent High charges (+3, -2) but covalent character reduces lattice energy compared to ideal ionic.
Copper(II) Oxide CuO Ionic/Covalent Moderate charges (+2, -2), significant covalent character affects lattice structure and energy.

Additional Information on Oxide Melting Points

Melting points of oxides are crucial properties for various applications, such as refractories (materials resistant to high temperatures). MgO, often called magnesia, is a well-known refractory material due to its extremely high melting point and chemical inertness at high temperatures. The melting point of a solid is the temperature at which it changes from a solid to a liquid state. For ionic solids, this transition requires overcoming the strong electrostatic forces within the crystal lattice. The stronger these forces (higher lattice energy), the more thermal energy (higher temperature) is needed to melt the substance.

Factors other than simple charge and size can also influence melting points, especially in compounds with significant covalent character or complex structures. These include crystal structure, directional covalent bonds, and Van der Waals forces, although in simple metal oxides, ionic lattice energy is often the dominant factor determining very high melting points.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from States of Matter

  1. A liquid is heated up to a certain temperature. Which one of the following situation would correspond to the boiling of the liquid?

  2. Equal volume of all gases, when measured at the same temperature and pressure, contain an equal number of particles. Who proposed the above law?

  3. Match List I with List II and select the correct answer using the code given below the Lists:

    List I (Noble gas)

    List II (Use)

    A. Argon

    1. In lights for advertising display

    B. Neon

    2. Airport landing lights and in light houses

    C. Krypton

    3. Light in photographer’s flash gun

    D. Xenon

    4. In tungsten filament to last

    Code:
  4. Match List-I with List-II and select the correct answer using the code given below the Lists:

    List I

    (Process)

    List II

    (Type of change)

    A. Heating of camphor

    1. Chemical

    B. Cooling of water vapor up to room temperature

    2. Evaporation

    C. Cooking an egg

    3. Condensation

    D. Formation of water vapor at room temperature.

    4. Sublimation

  5. The LPG cooking gas contains Propane and Butane as the constituents. A sulfur containing compound is added to the LPG, because

Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App