Which of the following statements about the Law Commission headed by Lord Macaulay is/are correct ? 1. It attempted to codify the laws. 2. It was opposed to uniform system of Courts. Select the correct answer using the code given below :
1 only
Understanding the Law Commission Led by Lord Macaulay
The question asks about two specific aspects of the Law Commission that was headed by Lord Macaulay. This commission played a very important role in shaping the legal system in British India. Let's look at the statements given.
Analyzing Statement 1: Attempt to Codify Laws
Statement 1 says that the Law Commission headed by Lord Macaulay attempted to codify the laws. Codification means arranging laws in a systematic code. The First Law Commission was indeed established under the Charter Act of 1833 with the primary aim of codifying Indian laws. Lord Macaulay was its first chairman. This commission worked extensively and its recommendations led to the drafting of significant legal codes, such as the Indian Penal Code (IPC) of 1860, the Code of Criminal Procedure of 1872, and the Code of Civil Procedure of 1908 (though enacted later, the foundation was laid by these early efforts). Therefore, it is correct that the Law Commission headed by Lord Macaulay attempted to codify the laws.
Analyzing Statement 2: Opposition to Uniform System of Courts
Statement 2 claims that the Law Commission headed by Lord Macaulay was opposed to a uniform system of Courts. The historical context suggests the opposite. Before the Law Commission's work, the judicial system in different parts of British India was quite fragmented and inconsistent. One of the goals of the British administration, and consequently the Law Commission, was to bring uniformity and consistency to both substantive law (the laws themselves) and the procedural law and the court system. The recommendations of the Law Commission and subsequent acts aimed at creating a more streamlined and uniform judicial administration. The eventual establishment of High Courts in Presidency towns (Calcutta, Bombay, Madras) under the Indian High Courts Act, 1861, which replaced the earlier Supreme Courts and Sadar Adalats, was a step towards judicial uniformity, influenced by the need for a more organized system that the Law Commission's work highlighted. Therefore, the commission was not opposed to, but rather contributed to the movement towards a uniform system of courts and law.
Conclusion on Statements
Based on the analysis:
- Statement 1: It attempted to codify the laws. This is correct.
- Statement 2: It was opposed to uniform system of Courts. This is incorrect.
Thus, only statement 1 is correct.
Revision Table: Macaulay Law Commission Key Aspects
| Aspect | Description regarding Macaulay's Law Commission |
|---|---|
| Establishment | First Law Commission (1834) under Charter Act of 1833 |
| Chairman | Lord Macaulay |
| Primary Objective | Codification of Indian Laws |
| Key Contribution | Drafting the Indian Penal Code (IPC) |
| Stance on Courts | Aimed towards uniformity and streamlining judicial administration |
Additional Information: Impact of Law Commissions in India
The tradition of Law Commissions continued in India after the First Law Commission. Subsequent Law Commissions were formed to further revise, consolidate, and codify various branches of law. The work started by the Law Commission under Lord Macaulay was foundational in creating a structured legal framework for India. The concept of codification brought clarity and accessibility to the laws, moving away from diverse, often unwritten, traditional laws.
Key takeaways regarding the Law Commission headed by Lord Macaulay:
- It was the beginning of systematic codification of laws in India.
- It did not oppose but facilitated the move towards a more uniform judicial system.
- Its work was crucial for the development of modern Indian law.
Similar Questions
Which one of the following statements about the IIbert Bill is correct?
Which one of the following statements about Subsidiary Alliance devised by Lord Wellesley in the year 1798 is NOT correct?
What was the consequence of Permanent Settlement on rural society in Bengal?
Which one of the following wasnota feature of the Subsidiary Alliance of Lord Wellesley?
Which one among the following Acts for the first time allowed Indians, at least theoretically, entry to higher posts in British Indian administration?
Consider the following statements:
1. Warren Hastings set up the Calcutta Madrassa for the study and teaching of Muslim law-related subjects.
2. Jonathan Duncan started a Sanskrit College at Varanasi for the study of Hindu law and philosophy.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?The British Officer who was a representative of the Governor General and who lived in a State which was not under direct British rule was called:
Which of the following features of the Permanent Settlements of 1793 is/are correct?
1. The Permanent Settlements vested land ownership rights in the peasants
2. The Permanent Settlement vested land ownership rights in the Zamindars
3. The Zamindars had to pay a fixed amount of rent by a particular date
4. The Zamindars benefited hugely from the Permanent Settlement while the peasants suffered
Select the correct answer using the code given below:
Which of the following statements about hill stations of colonial India is/are correct?
1. The architecture of hill stations sought to recreate the European style
2. Hill stations were developed as sanitariums where soldiers were treated for the illness
3. Shimla became the official residence of the Commander in Chief of the Indian army
4. In 1864, Shimla had to be evacuated because of a Typhoid epidemic
Select the correct answer using the code given below:
Who among the following was the author of Neel Darpan, published in 1860?
Important Questions from India under East India Company’s Rule
Which of the Governor Generals adopted the policy of Subsidiary Alliance with Indian States ?
Consider the following statements :
1. St. Francis Xavier was one of the founding members of the Jesuit Order.
2. St. Francis Xavier died in Goa and a church is dedicated to him there.
3. The Feast of St. Francis Xavier is celebrated in Goa each year.
Which of the statements given above are correct?
In which year was there a furore over the attempt by the government to introduce the Ilbert Bill by the white opposition that forced the government to withdraw the bill?
Name the treaty signed in 1826 at the end of the First Anglo-Burmese War. This treaty sealed the victory of the British powers.
The Ryotwari System was introduced by:
