All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Which among the following premises is not acceptable as an argument to prove that passive euthanasia is morally permissible but active euthanasia is not ?

This question was previously asked in
CUET PG 2026 Agri-Business Management Question Paper (25-Mar-2026) (Shift 2)
The correct answer is
The ultimate intention of the agent is most important for moral evaluation

Solution: Moral Permissibility of Euthanasia Arguments

The question asks to identify a premise that is unsuitable for arguing that passive euthanasia is morally acceptable while active euthanasia is not. We need to analyze each option to see if it supports this specific distinction.

Analyzing Euthanasia Premises

  • Option 1: Killing is worse than letting die
    This premise directly supports differentiating active euthanasia (killing) from passive euthanasia (letting die). It provides a moral basis for considering active euthanasia impermissible while passive euthanasia might be permissible. Thus, it IS acceptable for the argument.
  • Option 2: The ultimate intention of the agent is most important for moral evaluation
    This premise focuses solely on the agent's intention. While intentions differ between active and passive euthanasia, arguing that the *ultimate* intention in both could be the relief of suffering might blur the distinction required. If the primary goal in both cases is seen as alleviating suffering, this premise alone might not be sufficient to deem passive permissible and active impermissible, making it potentially *unacceptable* for this specific conclusion.
  • Option 3: "The actual causes of death" is relevant
    This premise allows distinguishing between the underlying disease causing death (passive) and the direct action causing death (active). This relevance provides a basis for moral differentiation, making it an acceptable premise for the argument.
  • Option 4: People who can kill constitute a morally worse society than those who let others die
    This premise frames the act of killing as inherently more morally problematic than letting die, supporting a distinction between active and passive euthanasia. It is therefore an acceptable premise for the argument.

Based on the analysis, the premise focusing solely on the paramount importance of ultimate intention (Option 2) is the one least likely to be acceptable for strictly proving passive euthanasia permissible while active euthanasia is not, as the ultimate intention might be argued as similar (e.g., ending suffering) in both scenarios.

Was this answer helpful?

Similar Questions

  1. Language, Truth and Logic was written by :
  2. Which of the following is not associated with Buddhist ethics ?
  3. Which of the following ideas does not belong to the philosophy of Descartes ?
  4. Which of the following is not included in Mill's experimental Method ?
  5. Which of the following is not included in the 'Laws of thought' ?
  6. Who among the following philosophers said that "Knowledge begins from sense experience, however it does not arise out of sense experience" ?
  7. Nyāya Bindu Tika is a text that belongs to which of the following school of thought in India ?
  8. There is an essential similarity between the subjugation of women and the subjugation of nature'. This idea is most closely related to which of the following feminist thinkers ?
  9. The concept of 'veil of ignorance' was given by which of the following political thinker ?
  10. Which of the following thinker identified the problem of 'Naturalistic Fallacy' in ethics ?

Important Questions from Mixed Topic (CUET PG)

  1. Which of the following variables are included in the Human Poverty Index?
    (A). The probability of not surviving till the age of 40.
    (B). The adult illiteracy rate.
    (C). The number of people who do not have access to clean water.
    (D). The number of small children who are underweight.
    Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
  2. Which of the following powers and responsibility are delegated to Panchayats?
    (A). to prepare plans and schemes for economic development
    (B). to promote schemes that will enhance social justice
    (C). to levy, collect and appropriate taxes, duties, tolls and fees
    (D). to help in the devolution of governmental responsibilities especially that of finances to local authorities
    Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
  3. Identify the sequence of art forms in India from East to West:
    (A). Bhaona
    (B). Jatra
    (C). Ramlila
    (D). Dashavatar
    (E). Maach
    Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
  4. Which of the following ideas does the concept of 'Sustainability' in Human Development refer to ?
    (A). Continuity in the availability of opportunities.
    (B). Each future generation must have higher opportunities (At least double) than their previous generation.
    (C). All environmental, financial and human resources must be used keeping in mind the future
    (D). Each generation must ensure the availability of choices and opportunities to its future generations.
    Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
  5. The sequence of stages in active listening is
    (A). Understanding
    (B). Remembering
    (C). Responding
    (D). Receiving
    (E) Evaluating

    Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Need Expert Advice?
Upcoming Exams
GATE
February 06, 2027
Test Series
CUET PG img
CUET
CUET PG Psychology (HUQP20) 2026 Mock Test Series
10 Tests
825 Attempts
3.7(15)
English
More Questions from CUET PG

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App