All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Students taking an exam are divided into two groups, P and Q such that each group has the same number of students. The performance of each of the students in a test was evaluated out of 200 marks. It was observed that the mean of group P was 105, while that of group Q was 85. The standard deviation of group P was 25, while that of group Q was 5. Assuming that the marks were distributed on a normal distribution, which of the following statements will have the highest probability of being TRUE?

The correct answer is

Most students of group Q scored marks in a narrower range than students in group P.

The question provides us with information about the test performance of students divided into two groups, P and Q. Both groups have the same number of students, and their marks are evaluated out of 200. We are given the mean and standard deviation for each group and are told that the marks are distributed on a normal distribution. Our task is to identify which statement has the highest probability of being true.

Understanding Key Statistical Concepts

Before analyzing the options, let's briefly understand the key statistical terms mentioned, as they are crucial for understanding student performance in an exam:

  • Mean (\(\mu\)): This is the average score of a group of students. It indicates the central tendency of the data distribution. A higher mean generally suggests better overall performance for the group.
  • Standard Deviation (\(\sigma\)): This measures the dispersion or spread of the student scores around the mean. A small standard deviation indicates that individual scores are clustered closely around the mean, implying a narrower range of scores for most students. A large standard deviation indicates that student scores are spread out over a wider range.
  • Normal Distribution: This is a common type of continuous probability distribution where the data points are symmetrically distributed around the mean, forming a bell-shaped curve. In a perfect normal distribution, the mean, median, and mode are all equal.

Exam Performance Data for Student Groups

Let's list the provided statistics for each student group:

Group Mean (\(\mu\)) Standard Deviation (\(\sigma\))
P 105 25
Q 85 5

Analyzing Each Probability Statement for Exam Scores

Now, let's evaluate each given option based on the provided statistics and the properties of a normal distribution to determine which statement regarding student performance has the highest probability of being true.

Probability of Statement 1: No student in group Q scored less marks than any student in group P.

  • This statement suggests that the minimum score achieved by any student in group Q is higher than or equal to the maximum score achieved by any student in group P.
  • Group P has a mean of 105 and a standard deviation of 25. Group Q has a mean of 85 and a standard deviation of 5.
  • Since Group P's mean (105) is significantly higher than Group Q's mean (85), it implies that Group P generally performs better. However, because both groups follow a normal distribution (meaning there are scores in the lower and upper tails of each distribution), it is highly improbable that every single student in Group Q scored higher than every single student in Group P. In fact, due to P's higher mean, it's more likely the opposite, but still, perfect separation is very unlikely.
  • Therefore, this statement has a very low probability of being true.

Probability of Statement 2: No student in group P scored less marks than any student in group Q.

  • This statement implies that the lowest score achieved by any student in group P is higher than or equal to the highest score achieved by any student in group Q.
  • Let's consider the approximate range for most scores in a normal distribution (e.g., within \(\pm3\sigma\) of the mean, which covers about 99.7% of the data):
    • For Group P: Approximate range is \(105 \pm 3 \times 25 = 105 \pm 75\), so marks could range from 30 to 180.
    • For Group Q: Approximate range is \(85 \pm 3 \times 5 = 85 \pm 15\), so marks could range from 70 to 100.
  • Comparing these ranges, it's clear that scores in Group P can go much lower (e.g., 30) than the highest scores in Group Q (e.g., 100). Therefore, it is quite possible and probable for some students in group P to score less marks (e.g., a student in P scoring 60) than some students in group Q (e.g., a student in Q scoring 95).
  • Hence, the statement that no student in group P scored less marks than any student in group Q is highly improbable.

Probability of Statement 3: Most students of group Q scored marks in a narrower range than students in group P.

  • This statement directly concerns the spread of the marks, which is measured by the standard deviation.
  • For Group Q, the standard deviation (\(\sigma_Q\)) is 5.
  • For Group P, the standard deviation (\(\sigma_P\)) is 25.
  • Since \(\sigma_Q = 5\) is significantly smaller than \(\sigma_P = 25\), it means that the scores of students in group Q are much more tightly clustered around their mean (85) compared to the scores of students in group P, which are more spread out around their mean (105).
  • In a normal distribution, a smaller standard deviation precisely indicates that a higher proportion of data points (i.e., most students) will fall within a smaller, narrower range around the mean. For example, about 68% of scores fall within \(\pm1\sigma\) of the mean:
    • For Group Q: \(85 \pm 1 \times 5\) = 80 to 90 (a range of 10 marks).
    • For Group P: \(105 \pm 1 \times 25\) = 80 to 130 (a range of 50 marks).
  • This comparison clearly demonstrates that "most students" in Group Q scored within a much narrower range of marks than those in Group P. Therefore, this statement has the highest probability of being true, directly reflecting the meaning of standard deviation.

Probability of Statement 4: The median of the marks of group P is 100.

  • For a perfectly normal distribution, the mean, median, and mode are all equal.
  • The question states that the marks were distributed on a normal distribution.
  • The given mean of group P (\(\mu_P\)) is 105.
  • Therefore, for group P, its median should also be 105, as the mean, median, and mode coincide in a normal distribution.
  • Since the statement claims the median is 100, this statement is false based on the properties of normal distribution and the provided mean.

Conclusion on Student Performance Data Analysis

Based on the detailed analysis of each statement concerning student performance, the statement that has the highest probability of being true is the one that correctly interprets the meaning of standard deviation in the context of a normal distribution. Group Q's significantly smaller standard deviation (5) compared to Group P's (25) directly implies that the marks of most students in Group Q are concentrated within a much narrower range around their mean.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Critical Reasoning

  1. Directions: A statement is given followed by two inferences I and II. You have to consider the statement to be true even if it seems to be at variance with commonly known facts. You have to decide which of the given inferences, if any, follow from the given statement.

    Statement: Many students are addicted to mobile games and this leads to poor academic performance.

    Inference:

    I. Many Students are not paying attention to studies due to mobile games.

    II. It is only because of mobile games that students fail in the examination. 

  2. 'Little knowledge is a dangerous thing' is a decision based on:

  3. It is better to spend the leftovers after saving. Financial discipline and self-control can make you rich. Saving money after spending is not a good habit. Which among the following statements is true as per the statement?

    A. If you spend first then you will be spendy.

    B. If you save before spending, you will become rich.

    C. If you spend before saving, you will be poor.

    D. Saving by borrowing is a bad habit.

  4. Which of the following is the assumption for the claim that 'Pleasure is desirable'?

  5. Read the given statements carefully and answer the questions.

    Fear of danger is more dangerous than danger itself. Risk is directly proportional= to danger

    Which of the following are true according to the given statements?

    A. Fear is worse than any fearful threat.

    B. There is a trade-off between risk and danger.

    C. There should be fear of danger.

    D. There is no need to take risks to overcome any danger.

Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App