All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Given question has main statement followed by four statements. Choose the ordered pair of statements, where the first statement implies the second, and the two statements are logically consistent with the main statement.

When she takes an examination, she clears it.

A. she took an examination

B. she did not take an examination

C. she cleared it.

D. she did not clear it.

The correct answer is

AC

Understanding the Main Statement

The main statement is: "When she takes an examination, she clears it." This is a classic example of a conditional statement, which can be represented in the form "If P, then Q".

  • Let P represent the statement: "she takes an examination".
  • Let Q represent the statement: "she clears it".

Therefore, the main statement can be written logically as: If P, then Q, or $P \implies Q$.

Analyzing the Options and Implications

We need to find an ordered pair of statements (X, Y) such that X implies Y ($X \implies Y$) and both X and Y are logically consistent with the main statement ($P \implies Q$).

Let's represent the given options:

  • A: "she took an examination" (P)
  • B: "she did not take an examination" (Not P)
  • C: "she cleared it." (Q)
  • D: "she did not clear it." (Not Q)

Analyzing Option Pairs:

  • Option 1: DA
    This suggests that "she did not clear it" (Not Q) implies "she took an examination" (P). The contrapositive of the main statement ($P \implies Q$) is "If Not Q, then Not P" (i.e., "If she did not clear it, then she did not take an examination"). Therefore, D does not imply A; it implies Not P. This pair is incorrect.
  • Option 2: AC
    This suggests that "she took an examination" (P) implies "she cleared it" (Q). This is precisely what the main statement says ($P \implies Q$). Both P ("she took an examination") and Q ("she cleared it") are part of the original conditional statement and are thus consistent with it. This implication ($P \implies Q$) is valid and consistent with the main statement.
  • Option 3: BC
    This suggests that "she did not take an examination" (Not P) implies "she cleared it" (Q). The main statement only tells us what happens *if* she takes the exam. It doesn't provide any information about whether she clears it or not if she *doesn't* take it. She might clear it for other reasons, or she might not. This implication is not guaranteed by the main statement. This pair is incorrect.
  • Option 4: CD
    This suggests that "she cleared it" (Q) implies "she did not clear it" (Not Q). This is a logical contradiction (Q implies Not Q). This pair is incorrect.

Conclusion

The only ordered pair where the first statement implies the second, and both are logically consistent with the main statement "When she takes an examination, she clears it" ($P \implies Q$), is AC.

Statement A (P) implies Statement C (Q), which is the core of the given conditional statement.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Critical Reasoning

  1. As a responsible person, which of the following is not advisable?

  2. A, B, and C have a few chocolates among themselves. A gives to each of the other two half the number of chocolates they already have. Similarly B and C (in that order) give each of the other two half the number of chocolates each of them already has. Now, if each of them has the same number of chocolates, what could be the minimum number of chocolates they have among themselves?
  3. You are alone in your house and there is a danger of thieves around. You hear a knock on the door. What should be your most logical action?

  4. While traveling in a train, you notice that a lady from the coach behind you falls from the stairs of the train. What should be your best rational course of action?

  5. Select the option, which is the logical equivalent of the statement given below: It is not true that both Hyderabad and Bangalore are in India.

Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App