A quote is given in this question after which a statement has been given. Read the quotation carefully and determine the statement based on the given quotation. Amazon has acknowledged a case of data breach (data secrecy rule violation) related to highlighting users' names and email IDs, without giving details about the nature or scope of the event. However, the company has not disclosed the total number of users affected by the violation. An email has been sent to all affected users, which notifies them only about technical error. And now, this e-commerce giant is presently offering gift cards as compensation to people affected by their data breech. The Seattle headquarters e-commerce company has also offered gift cards between $ 5 to $ 100 for some of those users, who have been affected by this violation. In a publication citing an email correspondence between Amazon and the customer, Paul Gagnon said that when he called the customer service desk of the company and questioned the leaked data, the company gave him a promotional certificate worth $ 100. Offered to deliver. When Gaganone could not be told about the data being leaked, then he was offered $ 100 as an apology. Many people affected by Breach filed a complaint with the company but none of them got any response from the company till now. It is being said that Amazon customers and supervisors have been instructed to not comment or offer an offer on any kind of compensation to affected Amazon users. "
Statement: The headquarters of many e-commerce companies like Amazon is located in Seattle. . select the appropriate option from the following options A - statement is definitely true. B - The statement is probably true. C - statement can not be determined. D - statement is definitely false.
C
Analyzing Statements Based on Given Text
This question asks us to evaluate a statement based *solely* on the information provided in the given quotation about an Amazon data breach.
Understanding the Statement
The statement we need to evaluate is: "The headquarters of many e-commerce companies like Amazon is located in Seattle."
Examining the Provided Text
Let's carefully read the quotation and extract relevant information:
- The text discusses a data breach involving Amazon.
- It mentions "The Seattle headquarters e-commerce company" when referring to Amazon. This confirms Amazon's headquarters is in Seattle.
- The text provides details about the breach, compensation offered by Amazon, and customer interactions.
- The text *only* mentions Amazon's headquarters location.
- The text *does not* provide any information about the headquarters locations of any other e-commerce companies.
Evaluating the Statement Against the Text
The statement makes two claims:
- Amazon's headquarters is in Seattle.
- The headquarters of *many* e-commerce companies *like* Amazon are also located in Seattle.
Based on the text:
- The first part, "The headquarters of... Amazon is located in Seattle," is confirmed by the phrase "The Seattle headquarters e-commerce company".
- The second part, "The headquarters of *many* e-commerce companies *like* Amazon is located in Seattle," is *not* mentioned or supported anywhere in the text. The text gives no information about the headquarters of any other e-commerce companies.
Since the text only provides information about Amazon's headquarters and no information about other e-commerce companies, we cannot determine whether "many" others are also located in Seattle based *only* on this passage.
Conclusion
Because the statement makes a claim about "many" other e-commerce companies, a claim for which the provided text offers no evidence or information, we cannot determine if the statement is true or false from the given passage.
Therefore, the statement "can not be determined."
Matching with Options
Based on our analysis, the statement "can not be determined" from the information in the quotation. This corresponds to option C.
The options were:
- A - statement is definitely true. (Incorrect, not enough information)
- B - The statement is probably true. (Incorrect, no basis to determine probability)
- C - statement can not be determined. (Correct, insufficient information in the text)
- D - statement is definitely false. (Incorrect, not enough information to prove it's false)
The correct option is C.
| Statement Component | Information in Text | Supported by Text? |
|---|---|---|
| Amazon's headquarters is in Seattle | "The Seattle headquarters e-commerce company" | Yes |
| Headquarters of *many* other e-commerce companies are in Seattle | No information provided about other companies | No |
Revision Table: Statement Evaluation
When evaluating a statement based on a passage, focus strictly on the information given. Do not use outside knowledge.
| If Text... | And Statement... | Conclusion | Option |
|---|---|---|---|
| Directly supports the entire statement | Matches text exactly | Definitely true | A |
| Contradicts the entire statement | Is opposite of text | Definitely false | D |
| Provides strong evidence but not absolute certainty | Likely true based on text | Probably true | B |
| Provides strong evidence suggesting falsehood | Likely false based on text | Probably false | (Often grouped with D or E/F) |
| Does not contain enough information to confirm or deny the statement | Makes claims beyond text's scope | Cannot be determined | C |
Additional Information: Reading Comprehension Skills
This type of question tests your reading comprehension and ability to draw conclusions *only* from the provided text. It's crucial to distinguish between what the text explicitly states or strongly implies and what might be true in the real world but is not mentioned in the passage.
- Stick to the Text: Avoid using external knowledge. Even if you know many tech companies are in Seattle, the passage doesn't say that about *e-commerce* companies besides Amazon.
- Identify Claims: Break down the statement into its core claims.
- Scan for Evidence: Reread the text specifically looking for information that supports or refutes each claim.
- Assess Sufficiency: Determine if the information found is sufficient to definitively prove, probably prove, definitively disprove, or probably disprove the entire statement. If not, the answer is "cannot be determined".
Important Questions from Statements and Inferences
“India is a country of rich heritage and cultural diversity.”
Which one of the following facts best supports the claim made in the above sentence?
Yoga has become a very popular exercise today. But before one joins a yoga class, he/she needs to examine the kind of fitness routine that he/she expects. If one is looking for a high energy, fast-paced aerobic workout, a yoga class might not be the best choice. The statement that best supports this paragraph is
An honest king decided to give death penalty to his minister for some mistake. But he gave him two options: "If you tell correctly what I am thinking now, you will be hanged. But if your guess is wrong, you will be killed by throwing to crocodiles". The clever minister made a statement such that the king could not kill him. The statement made by the minister is
Sita is a twelve year old girl. For many years, she has been asking her parents for a pet dog. Her parents told her that a dog would not be happy in an apartment, but they have given her permission to have a bird. Sita has not yet decided what kind of bird she would like to have. The statement that best supports this paragraph is
Two person S and M have made the following statement among themselves
S say that I am certainly not over 40 year.
M says that I am 38 years and you are at least 5 years older than me.
S says you are at least 39 years.
If all the above statements are wrong, what are the ages of M and S?
