Read the given statements and conclusions carefully and choose which of the conclusions logically follows from the statement. Statement : I. Some trinkets are silver. II. All silver are metals. Conclusion : 1. Some silver are trinket. 2. Some metals are trinkets.
Both conclusions 1 and 2 follows
This question tests your ability to draw logical conclusions from given statements. We are given two statements and two conclusions and need to determine which conclusions logically follow from the statements.
Let's break down the provided statements:
Now, let's look at the conclusions we need to evaluate:
Statement I says, "Some trinkets are silver." This is a particular affirmative statement (I type). A standard immediate inference rule states that the converse of an 'I' type statement ("Some A are B") is "Some B are A," which is always valid.
Applying this rule to Statement I:
Conclusion 1 is exactly the converse of Statement I. Therefore, Conclusion 1 logically follows from Statement I.
To evaluate Conclusion 2, we need to combine the information from both statements.
We have a 'Some A are B' statement followed by an 'All B are C' statement. A common rule in syllogism states that if "Some A are B" and "All B are C", then "Some A are C" is a valid conclusion.
Applying this rule:
So, we can conclude "Some trinkets are metals". Conclusion 2, however, is "Some metals are trinkets". This is the converse of "Some trinkets are metals". As established earlier, the converse of an 'I' type statement ("Some A are C") is "Some C are A", which is valid.
Therefore, since "Some trinkets are metals" is a valid deduction from the statements, its converse, "Some metals are trinkets," is also a valid conclusion. Conclusion 2 logically follows from the given statements.
| Conclusion | Evaluation | Follows? |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Some silver are trinket. | Converse of Statement I ("Some trinkets are silver"). Converse of I-type is valid. | Yes |
| 2. Some metals are trinkets. | Inference from combining Statement I and II ("Some trinkets are silver" + "All silver are metals" → "Some trinkets are metals"), then taking the converse ("Some trinkets are metals" → "Some metals are trinkets"). Both steps are valid. | Yes |
Based on the analysis, both Conclusion 1 and Conclusion 2 logically follow from the given statements.
| Statement Type | Structure | Quantifier | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| A (Universal Affirmative) | All P are Q | All | All birds are animals. |
| E (Universal Negative) | No P are Q | No | No dog is a cat. |
| I (Particular Affirmative) | Some P are Q | Some | Some fruits are sweet. |
| O (Particular Negative) | Some P are not Q | Some...not | Some students are not present. |
In syllogism, we can draw conclusions in two main ways:
In this problem, Conclusion 1 uses immediate inference (converse of 'I'). Conclusion 2 uses a combination of mediate inference (combining statements I & II to get "Some trinkets are metals") and then immediate inference (taking the converse to get "Some metals are trinkets"). Both steps are crucial for understanding why Conclusion 2 follows.
Read the given statements and conclusions carefully. Assuming that the information given in the statements is true, even if it appears to be at variance with commonly known facts, decide which of the given conclusions logically follow(s) from the statements.
Statements:
All forests are hills.
Some hills are deserts.
Conclusions:
(I): All hills are forests.
(II): Some deserts are hills.
Read the given statements and conclusions carefully. Assuming that the information given in the statements is true, even if it appears to be at variance with commonly known facts, decide which of the given conclusions logically follow(s) from the statements.
Statements:
All bottles are ludo.
All ludo are dancer.
Conclusions:
(I): Some dancers are ludo.
(II): All bottles are dancers.