Assertion (A) : According to the exponents of Monism Theory, law is a Unified branch of knowledge, no matter whether it applies on persons or other entities.
Reason (R) : In view of the Monistic writers, in the ultimate analysis of the law we find that man is at the root to all laws.
Monism Theory: Assertion Analysis
Assertion (A) states that exponents of Monism Theory view law as a single, unified body of knowledge, applicable universally whether to individuals or other entities. This aligns with the core idea of monism, which posits unity or a single source. Therefore, Assertion (A) is considered correct.
Monism Theory: Reason Analysis
Reason (R) suggests that Monistic writers believe 'man' is the fundamental origin ('root') of all laws. This points to an anthropocentric source for law, which is a common perspective in many legal theories that seek a singular foundation for legal rules, such as those derived from human will or reason. Therefore, Reason (R) is also considered correct.
Relationship Between Assertion and Reason
While both statements (A) and (R) reflect valid aspects potentially associated with Monism Theory in legal thought, Reason (R) does not directly explain *why* law is considered a unified branch of knowledge as stated in Assertion (A). The unity of law (A) might stem from its systematic construction, a single sovereign source (like in legal positivism), or a universal ethical principle, rather than solely from 'man' being its root (R). Therefore, (R) is not the correct explanation for (A).
Conclusion
Based on the analysis:
- Assertion (A) is correct.
- Reason (R) is correct.
- Reason (R) does not correctly explain Assertion (A).
This matches Option B.
Important Questions from Public International Law
- "International law is the body of rules and principles of action which are binding upon civilised states in their relations with one another". This definition is attributed to whom of the following?
- Which of the following is a landmark case on the importance of 'nationality'?
- Arrange the following Conventions in the chronological order of their coming into force.
A. The Biological Weapons Convention
B. The Chemical Weapons Convention
C. The Conventional Weapons Convention
D. The Ottawa Convention on Anti-Personnel Mines
Choose the correct answer from the options given below: - Which of the following decisions are related to extradition:
A. Savarkar case
B. Abu Salem case
C. Castioni, re case
D. Meunier, re case
E. Paquete Habana case
Choose the correct answer from the options given below: - Match the LIST-I with LIST-II
LIST-I Maxim LIST-II Meaning A. Erga Omnes I. Relation to all B. Jus Cogens II. Peremptory norm C. Pacta Sunt Servanda III. Agreements are to be respected D. Rebus Sic Stantibus IV. Essential circumstances remain unchanged
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
