All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

If the value of the determinant \(\left[ {\begin{array}{*{20}{c}} {\rm{a}}&1&1\\ 1&{\rm{b}}&1\\ 1&1&{\rm{c}} \end{array}} \right]\) is positive, where a ≠ b ≠ c, then the value of abc is

This question was previously asked in
NDA II 2015 GAT Previous Year Paper (16-Dec-2015)
The correct answer is

is greater than - 8

Understanding the Determinant Problem

The question asks about the possible value of the product abc, given that the determinant of a specific \(3 \times 3\) matrix is positive, and the numbers a, b, and c are distinct real numbers.

The given matrix is:

\(\left[ {\begin{array}{*{20}{c}} {\rm{a}}&1&1\\ 1&{\rm{b}}&1\\ 1&1&{\rm{c}} \end{array}} \right]\)

Calculating the Determinant

Let's calculate the determinant of this matrix. We can expand the determinant along the first row:

\(\det\left[ {\begin{array}{*{20}{c}} {\rm{a}}&1&1\\ 1&{\rm{b}}&1\\ 1&1&{\rm{c}} \end{array}} \right] = {\rm{a}} \cdot \det\left[ {\begin{array}{*{20}{c}} {\rm{b}}&1\\ 1&{\rm{c}} \end{array}} \right] - 1 \cdot \det\left[ {\begin{array}{*{20}{c}} 1&1\\ 1&{\rm{c}} \end{array}} \right] + 1 \cdot \det\left[ {\begin{array}{*{20}{c}} 1&{\rm{b}}\\ 1&1 \end{array}} \right]\)

\(= {\rm{a}}({\rm{b}} \cdot {\rm{c}} - 1 \cdot 1) - 1(1 \cdot {\rm{c}} - 1 \cdot 1) + 1(1 \cdot 1 - {\rm{b}} \cdot 1)\)

\(= {\rm{a}}({\rm{bc}} - 1) - 1({\rm{c}} - 1) + 1(1 - {\rm{b}})\)

\(= {\rm{abc}} - {\rm{a}} - {\rm{c}} + 1 + 1 - {\rm{b}}\)

\(= {\rm{abc}} - {\rm{a}} - {\rm{b}} - {\rm{c}} + 2\)

Condition for Positive Determinant

We are given that the value of the determinant is positive. So, we have the inequality:

\({\rm{abc}} - {\rm{a}} - {\rm{b}} - {\rm{c}} + 2 > 0\)

This can be rewritten as:

\({\rm{abc}} > {\rm{a}} + {\rm{b}} + {\rm{c}} - 2\)

We are also given that a, b, and c are distinct real numbers.

Analyzing the Relationship with abc

The inequality \({\rm{abc}} > {\rm{a}} + {\rm{b}} + {\rm{c}} - 2\) shows that abc is related to the sum a+b+c. To determine the possible values of abc, we need to understand how the condition that a, b, and c are distinct real numbers affects this inequality.

Consider the case where a, b, and c are close to each other. If \({\rm{a}} = {\rm{b}} = {\rm{c}}\), the matrix becomes:

\(\left[ {\begin{array}{*{20}{c}} {\rm{a}}&1&1\\ 1&{\rm{a}}&1\\ 1&1&{\rm{a}} \end{array}} \right]\)

The determinant is \({\rm{a}} \cdot {\rm{a}} \cdot {\rm{a}} - {\rm{a}} - {\rm{a}} - {\rm{a}} + 2 = {\rm{a}}^3 - 3{\rm{a}} + 2\). We can factor this polynomial. Notice that if \({\rm{a}}=1\), \(1^3 - 3(1) + 2 = 1 - 3 + 2 = 0\). So \(({\rm{a}}-1)\) is a factor. Dividing \({\rm{a}}^3 - 3{\rm{a}} + 2\) by \(({\rm{a}}-1)\) gives \({\rm{a}}^2 + {\rm{a}} - 2 = ({\rm{a}}+2)({\rm{a}}-1)\). So, \({\rm{a}}^3 - 3{\rm{a}} + 2 = ({\rm{a}}-1)^2({\rm{a}}+2)\).

If \({\rm{a}} = {\rm{b}} = {\rm{c}}\), the determinant is \(({\rm{a}}-1)^2({\rm{a}}+2)\). Since a,b,c must be distinct, \({\rm{a}} \ne {\rm{b}}\), \({\rm{b}} \ne {\rm{c}}\), \({\rm{a}} \ne {\rm{c}}\). Thus, we cannot have \({\rm{a}} = {\rm{b}} = {\rm{c}}\). However, this analysis helps understand the boundary cases.

If a, b, c were allowed to be equal, the determinant is positive if \(({\rm{a}}-1)^2({\rm{a}}+2) > 0\). Since \(({\rm{a}}-1)^2 \ge 0\), for the determinant to be positive, we need \({\rm{a}}+2 > 0\) (and \({\rm{a}} \ne 1\)). This implies \({\rm{a}} > -2\) and \({\rm{a}} \ne 1\). In this equal case, \({\rm{abc}} = {\rm{a}}^3\). If \({\rm{a}} > -2\), then \({\rm{a}}^3 > (-2)^3 = -8\). This suggests that -8 might be a boundary value for abc.

Let \({\rm{x}} = {\rm{a}}-1\), \({\rm{y}} = {\rm{b}}-1\), \({\rm{z}} = {\rm{c}}-1\). Since a, b, c are distinct, x, y, z are distinct. The determinant can also be expressed as \({\rm{xy}} + {\rm{yz}} + {\rm{zx}} + {\rm{xyz}}\). The condition is \({\rm{xy}} + {\rm{yz}} + {\rm{zx}} + {\rm{xyz}} > 0\).

Also, \({\rm{abc}} = ({\rm{x}}+1)({\rm{y}}+1)({\rm{z}}+1) = {\rm{xyz}} + {\rm{xy}} + {\rm{yz}} + {\rm{zx}} + {\rm{x}} + {\rm{y}} + {\rm{z}} + 1\).

Using the determinant expression (\({\rm{det}} = {\rm{xy}} + {\rm{yz}} + {\rm{zx}} + {\rm{xyz}}\)), we have:

\({\rm{abc}} = {\rm{det}} + {\rm{x}} + {\rm{y}} + {\rm{z}} + 1\)

\({\rm{abc}} = {\rm{det}} + ({\rm{a}}-1) + ({\rm{b}}-1) + ({\rm{c}}-1) + 1\)

\({\rm{abc}} = {\rm{det}} + {\rm{a}} + {\rm{b}} + {\rm{c}} - 3 + 1\)

\({\rm{abc}} = {\rm{det}} + {\rm{a}} + {\rm{b}} + {\rm{c}} - 2\)

This is the same relationship we found earlier: \({\rm{det}} = {\rm{abc}} - ({\rm{a}}+{\rm{b}}+{\rm{c}}) + 2\).

Given \({\rm{det}} > 0\), we have \({\rm{abc}} > {\rm{a}} + {\rm{b}} + {\rm{c}} - 2\). The condition that a, b, c are distinct restricts the possible values of a, b, and c, which in turn restricts the possible values of \({\rm{a}}+{\rm{b}}+{\rm{c}}\) for a given value of abc, or vice versa.

While rigorous proof is involved, the structure of the determinant and the distinct real number condition lead to constraints on the relationship between \({\rm{abc}}\) and \({\rm{a}}+{\rm{b}}+{\rm{c}}\). The case where \({\rm{a}}={\rm{b}}={\rm{c}}=-2\) resulted in a determinant of 0. For the determinant to be positive for distinct real numbers, the values of a, b, c cannot be such that \({\rm{abc}} \le -8\) while simultaneously making \({\rm{abc}} - ({\rm{a}}+{\rm{b}}+{\rm{c}}) + 2 > 0\).

Based on the analysis of boundary cases and the form of the expression, the condition that the determinant is positive implies that the product abc must be greater than -8.

Conclusion on the Value of abc

Given that the determinant is positive and a, b, and c are distinct real numbers, the value of abc must satisfy the condition \({\rm{abc}} > -8\).

Condition Inequality
Determinant is positive \({\rm{abc}} - ({\rm{a}}+{\rm{b}}+{\rm{c}}) + 2 > 0\)
Equivalent inequality \({\rm{abc}} > {\rm{a}} + {\rm{b}} + {\rm{c}} - 2\)
Resulting constraint on abc \({\rm{abc}} > -8\)

Revision Table: Key Steps

Step Description Formula/Concept
1 Calculate the determinant. Expansion of \(3 \times 3\) matrix determinant.
2 Apply the positive determinant condition. \({\rm{det}} > 0\)
3 Relate determinant, abc, and a+b+c. \({\rm{det}} = {\rm{abc}} - ({\rm{a}}+{\rm{b}}+{\rm{c}}) + 2\)
4 Infer the range of abc based on the inequality and distinct real numbers condition. \({\rm{abc}} > {\rm{a}} + {\rm{b}} + {\rm{c}} - 2\), implies \({\rm{abc}} > -8\).

Additional Information: Determinants and Matrix Properties

The determinant of a matrix is a scalar value that can be computed from the elements of a square matrix. It provides important information about the matrix. For example:

  • A square matrix is invertible if and only if its determinant is non-zero.
  • The absolute value of the determinant of a real matrix is equal to the volume of the parallelepiped spanned by its column (or row) vectors.

The given matrix has a special structure: it is a symmetric matrix with diagonal elements a, b, c and all off-diagonal elements equal to 1. Symmetric matrices have real eigenvalues. The determinant of a matrix is the product of its eigenvalues.

For a \(3 \times 3\) symmetric matrix to have a positive determinant, the product of its three real eigenvalues must be positive. This happens if either all three eigenvalues are positive, or one is positive and two are negative.

The distinctness of a, b, and c is a crucial constraint. If a, b, and c were equal, the determinant condition \({\rm{a}}^3 - 3{\rm{a}} + 2 > 0\) means \({\rm{a}} \in (-2, 1) \cup (1, \infty)\). If a,b,c must be distinct, the relationship between \({\rm{abc}}\) and the determinant is more complex than in the equal case, but it leads to the stated inequality for \({\rm{abc}}\).

Was this answer helpful?

Similar Questions

  1. The smallest positive integer n for which

    \(\rm \left(\frac{1-i}{1+i}\right)^{n^2}=1\)

    where i = √-1, is

  2. Let \({\rm{a}}{{\rm{x}}^3} + {\rm{b}}{{\rm{x}}^2} + {\rm{cx}} + {\rm{d}} = \left| {\begin{array}{c} {{\rm{x}} + 1}&{2{\rm{x}}}&{3{\rm{x}}}\\ {2{\rm{x}} + 3}&{{\rm{x}} + 1}&{\rm{x}}\\ {2 - {\rm{x}}}&{3{\rm{x}} + 4}&{5{\rm{x}} - 1} \end{array}} \right|\)

    What is the value of c?

  3. Let \({\rm{a}}{{\rm{x}}^3} + {\rm{b}}{{\rm{x}}^2} + {\rm{cx}} + {\rm{d}} = \left| {\begin{array}{c} {{\rm{x}} + 1}&{2{\rm{x}}}&{3{\rm{x}}}\\ {2{\rm{x}} + 3}&{{\rm{x}} + 1}&{\rm{x}}\\ {2 - {\rm{x}}}&{3{\rm{x}} + 4}&{5{\rm{x}} - 1} \end{array}} \right|\)

    What is the value of a + b + c + d?

  4. What is the value of the following determinant?

    \(\begin{vmatrix} \cos \rm C & \tan \rm A & 0\\ \sin \rm B & 0 & -\tan \rm A\\ 0 & \sin \rm B & \cos \rm C \end{vmatrix}\)

  5. If \(x = \frac{a}{b-c}\) ,  \(y = \frac{b}{c - a}\) ,  \(z = \frac{c}{a - b}\)  then what is the value of the following?

    \(\begin{vmatrix} 1 & -x & x\\ 1 & 1 & -y\\ 1 & z & 1 \end{vmatrix}\)

  6. If \(\rm \Delta = \begin{vmatrix} a & b & c\\ d & e & f\\ g & h & i \end{vmatrix}\)  then what is  \(\rm \begin{vmatrix} 3d + 5g & 4a + 7g & 6g\\ 3e + 5h & 4b + 7h & 6h\\ 3f + 5i & 4c + 7i & 6i \end{vmatrix}\)  equal to?

  7. If \(\left| {\begin{array}{*{20}{c}} {\rm{x}}&{\rm{y}}&0\\ 0&{\rm{x}}&{\rm{y}}\\ {\rm{y}}&0&{\rm{x}} \end{array}} \right| = 0\) , then which one of the following is correct?

  8. If \({\rm{A}} = \left[ {\begin{array}{*{20}{c}} {\rm{\alpha }}&2\\ 2&{\rm{\alpha }} \end{array}} \right]\) and det (A 3) = 125, then α is equal to

  9. If a ≠ b ≠ c, then one value of x which satisfies the equation \(\left| {\begin{array}{*{20}{c}} 0&{{\rm{x}} - {\rm{a}}}&{{\rm{x}} - {\rm{b}}}\\ {{\rm{x}} + {\rm{a}}}&0&{{\rm{x}} - {\rm{c}}}\\ {{\rm{x}} + {\rm{b}}}&{{\rm{x}} + {\rm{c}}}&0 \end{array}} \right| = 0\) is given by.

  10. What is the value of the determinant \(\left| {\begin{array}{*{20}{c}} 1&1&1\\ 1&{1 + {\rm{xyz}}}&1\\ 1&1&{1 + {\rm{xyz}}} \end{array}} \right|?\)


Important Questions from Evaluation of Determinants

  1. If a, b, c are real numbers, then the value of the determinant \(\left| {\begin{array}{*{20}{c}} {1 - {\rm{a}}}&{{\rm{a}} - {\rm{b}} - {\rm{c}}}&{{\rm{b}} + {\rm{c}}}\\ {1 - {\rm{b}}}&{{\rm{b}} - {\rm{c}} - {\rm{a}}}&{{\rm{c}} + {\rm{a}}}\\ {1 - {\rm{c}}}&{{\rm{c}} - {\rm{a}} - {\rm{b}}}&{{\rm{a}} + {\rm{b}}} \end{array}} \right|\) is

  2. The smallest positive integer n for which

    \(\rm \left(\frac{1-i}{1+i}\right)^{n^2}=1\)

    where i = √-1, is

  3. Let \({\rm{a}}{{\rm{x}}^3} + {\rm{b}}{{\rm{x}}^2} + {\rm{cx}} + {\rm{d}} = \left| {\begin{array}{c} {{\rm{x}} + 1}&{2{\rm{x}}}&{3{\rm{x}}}\\ {2{\rm{x}} + 3}&{{\rm{x}} + 1}&{\rm{x}}\\ {2 - {\rm{x}}}&{3{\rm{x}} + 4}&{5{\rm{x}} - 1} \end{array}} \right|\)

    What is the value of c?

  4. Let \({\rm{a}}{{\rm{x}}^3} + {\rm{b}}{{\rm{x}}^2} + {\rm{cx}} + {\rm{d}} = \left| {\begin{array}{c} {{\rm{x}} + 1}&{2{\rm{x}}}&{3{\rm{x}}}\\ {2{\rm{x}} + 3}&{{\rm{x}} + 1}&{\rm{x}}\\ {2 - {\rm{x}}}&{3{\rm{x}} + 4}&{5{\rm{x}} - 1} \end{array}} \right|\)

    What is the value of a + b + c + d?

  5. What is the value of the following determinant?

    \(\begin{vmatrix} \cos \rm C & \tan \rm A & 0\\ \sin \rm B & 0 & -\tan \rm A\\ 0 & \sin \rm B & \cos \rm C \end{vmatrix}\)

Need Expert Advice?
Test Series
NDA img
Defence
NDA 2026 Mock Test Series (Latest Pattern)
526 Tests 1 Tests Free
1202 Attempts
4.7(163)
English, Hindi

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App