Assertion (A) : For Plato great diversity of wealth was inconsistent with good government.
Reason (R) : He saw no way to abolish the evil except by abolishing wealth itself, so far as soldiers and rulers are concerned.
Codes :
Plato's View on Wealth and Governance
This question examines Plato's philosophy regarding the relationship between wealth and the quality of government, specifically his views presented in works like The Republic.
Analyzing Assertion (A): Wealth Diversity and Government
Assertion (A) states that Plato believed great diversity of wealth was inconsistent with good government. Plato argued that significant differences in wealth within a society could lead to social division, corruption, and instability. He saw wealth as a potential source of conflict and believed that an ideal state, the Kallipolis, should strive for unity and harmony, which extreme wealth disparity undermines. Therefore, Assertion (A) is true according to Plato's political theory.
Analyzing Reason (R): Abolishing Wealth for Rulers
Reason (R) suggests that Plato saw abolishing wealth, specifically for soldiers and rulers, as the only way to eliminate its negative effects. In Plato's ideal state, the guardian class (rulers and soldiers) were prohibited from owning private property or accumulating personal wealth. This measure aimed to prevent greed and ensure that their focus remained solely on governing for the common good, rather than personal enrichment. This reflects Plato's belief that removing the temptation and corrupting influence of wealth from those in power was essential for maintaining a just and stable government. Therefore, Reason (R) is also a true representation of Plato's ideas.
Connecting Reason (R) to Assertion (A)
Reason (R) directly explains why Plato found wealth diversity problematic (Assertion A). By proposing the abolition of private wealth for the ruling class, Plato offered a solution to mitigate the negative impacts of wealth accumulation he observed. This solution was designed to ensure the rulers' incorruptibility and dedication, thereby contributing to a good government, which he believed was threatened by economic inequality.
Since both statements are accurate descriptions of Plato's thought and Reason (R) provides the specific mechanism Plato proposed to address the problem stated in Assertion (A), Reason (R) is a correct explanation of Assertion (A).
Important Questions from Political Theory
Match List - I with List - II and select the correct answer using the codes given below :
List - I List - II a. Hegel i. Juridical b. Austin ii. Sociological c. Maclver iii. Descriptive d. Garner iv. Metaphysical Who among the following propounded the monotheistic theory of sovereignty?
"All within the State, none outside the State, none against the State". This statement points to a
Legal sovereign is the certain authority which can legitimately express the highest orders of the State, who can disregard divine law, moral principle and public opinion. This definition is given by
Who has written that, "it is better to be a Socrates dissatisfied than a pig satisfied"?
