The number of spin-allowed d-d transitions in a complex ion depends on its electronic configuration, geometry, and the ligand field splitting. For a complex ion to exhibit three spin-allowed d-d transitions, there must be at least three distinct energy levels accessible from the ground state via transitions between split d-orbitals, without changing the spin multiplicity.
Analyzing Complex Ions for Three Spin-Allowed d-d Transitions
We analyze each complex ion presented in the options:
1. $[V(H2O)6]3+$
- Metal ion: V3+
- Electronic configuration: $d2$
- Geometry: Octahedral (Oh)
- Splitting: $t2g$ and $eg$ levels
- Ground state term symbol (Oh): $3T1g(F)$
- Transitions: Three spin-allowed transitions occur: $3T1g(F)$ $\rightarrow$ $3T2g$, $3T1g(F)$ $\rightarrow$ $3T1g(P)$, and $3T1g(F)$ $\rightarrow$ $3A2g$.
- Verdict: Exhibits three spin-allowed d-d transitions.
2. $[Ni(H2O)6]2+$
- Metal ion: Ni2+
- Electronic configuration: $d8$
- Geometry: Octahedral (Oh)
- Splitting: $t2g$ and $eg$ levels
- Ground state term symbol (Oh): $3A2g$
- Transitions: Three spin-allowed transitions occur: $3A2g$ $\rightarrow$ $3T2g$, $3A2g$ $\rightarrow$ $3T1g(F)$, and $3A2g$ $\rightarrow$ $3T1g(P)$.
- Verdict: Exhibits three spin-allowed d-d transitions.
3. $[Cr(H2O)6]3+$
- Metal ion: Cr3+
- Electronic configuration: $d3$
- Geometry: Octahedral (Oh)
- Splitting: $t2g$ and $eg$ levels
- Ground state term symbol (Oh): $4A2g$
- Transitions: Three spin-allowed transitions occur: $4A2g$ $\rightarrow$ $4T2g$, $4A2g$ $\rightarrow$ $4T1g(F)$, and $4A2g$ $\rightarrow$ $4T1g(P)$.
- Verdict: Exhibits three spin-allowed d-d transitions.
4. $[NiCl4]2-$
- Metal ion: Ni2+
- Electronic configuration: $d8$
- Geometry: Tetrahedral (Td)
- Splitting: $A2$, $T1$, $T2$, $E$ levels (different order than Oh)
- Ground state term symbol (Td): $3A2$
- Transitions: Three spin-allowed transitions occur: $3A2$ $\rightarrow$ $3T2$, $3A2$ $\rightarrow$ $3T1(F)$, and $3A2$ $\rightarrow$ $3T1(P)$.
- Verdict: Exhibits three spin-allowed d-d transitions.
5. $[Ti(H2O)6]3+$
- Metal ion: Ti3+
- Electronic configuration: $d1$
- Geometry: Octahedral (Oh)
- Transitions: Only one spin-allowed transition possible: $t2g$ $\rightarrow$ $eg$ ($2T2g$ $\rightarrow$ $2Eg$).
- Verdict: Exhibits only one spin-allowed d-d transition.
6. $[Mn(H2O)6]2+$
- Metal ion: Mn2+
- Electronic configuration: $d5$ (high spin)
- Geometry: Octahedral (Oh)
- Ground state term symbol (Oh): $6A1g$
- Transitions: Only one spin-allowed transition: $6A1g$ $\rightarrow$ $6T1g$. Other transitions are spin-forbidden.
- Verdict: Exhibits only one spin-allowed d-d transition.
7. $[FeF6]3-$
- Metal ion: Fe3+
- Electronic configuration: $d5$ (high spin)
- Geometry: Octahedral (Oh)
- Ground state term symbol (Oh): $6A1g$
- Transitions: Only one spin-allowed transition: $6A1g$ $\rightarrow$ $6T1g$. Other transitions are spin-forbidden.
- Verdict: Exhibits only one spin-allowed d-d transition.
8. $[FeCl4]2-$
- Metal ion: Fe2+
- Electronic configuration: $d6$
- Geometry: Tetrahedral (Td)
- Ground state term symbol (Td): $5E$
- Transitions: Two spin-allowed transitions: $5E$ $\rightarrow$ $5T2$ and $5E$ $\rightarrow$ $5T1$.
- Verdict: Exhibits two spin-allowed d-d transitions.
Conclusion
Based on the analysis:
- Option A: $[V(H2O)6]3+$ (3 transitions) and $[Ni(H2O)6]2+$ (3 transitions) are both correct.
- Option B: $[Cr(H2O)6]3+$ (3 transitions) and $[NiCl4]2-$ (3 transitions) are both correct.
- Option C: $[Ti(H2O)6]3+$ (1 transition) and $[Mn(H2O)6]2+$ (1 transition) are incorrect.
- Option D: $[FeF6]3-$ (1 transition) and $[FeCl4]2-$ (2 transitions) are incorrect.
Therefore, the correct pairs are those in options A and B.