City A is located to the North of city B. City D is located to the East of city B. City C is located to the West of city D. City É is located to the South of city C and to the South- West of city A. What is the position of city B with respect to city C?
East
This question asks us to determine the position of one city (city B) relative to another city (city C) based on a series of directional clues connecting several cities (A, B, C, D, and E). These types of problems require careful spatial reasoning to build a mental map or draw a diagram of the cities' relative locations.
Let's break down each statement provided in the question:
We know the positions of A and D relative to B. A is North of B, and D is East of B. We also know C is West of D. Let's consider the relationship involving E.
City E is South of city C, and City E is South-West of city A.
Let's think about this:
Since C is directly North of E, and E is South-West of A, it implies that C must be located somewhere to the West of A. Why? Because if C were directly North of E, and E is to the West of the vertical line passing through A (since E is South-WEST of A), then C must also be to the West of the vertical line passing through A.
Now let's bring in the relationship between C, B, and D. We know C is West of D, and D is East of B. So both B and C are located somewhere to the West of D.
We established that C is West of A. We know A is North of B.
Consider the possibilities for C relative to B:
Therefore, based on the condition involving city E, city C must be located to the West of city B. This arrangement is also consistent with C being West of D, as D is East of B, so any point West of B is also West of D.
The question asks for the position of city B with respect to city C. We concluded that city C is located to the West of city B.
If City C is West of City B, then City B must be located to the East of City C.
| Relationship | Spatial Implication |
|---|---|
| A is North of B | A is located upwards from B |
| D is East of B | D is located to the right of B |
| C is West of D | C is located to the left of D (could be East or West of B) |
| E is South of C | E is located downwards from C |
| E is South-West of A | E is located downwards and to the left from A |
| Deduction (from E's position): C is West of A | C is located to the left of the North-South line through A |
| Deduction (combining C West of A and A North of B): C is West of B | C is located to the left of B |
Final Answer Derivation:
Since City C is West of City B, City B is East of City C.
By carefully analyzing all the directional relationships, especially the constraint involving city E's position relative to both A and C, we determined the spatial layout. City C must be located to the West of city B. Therefore, city B is located to the East of city C.
| Statement | Implied B-C/C-B Relation? | Consistency Check |
|---|---|---|
| A is N of B | No direct B-C link | Used to fix A relative to B |
| D is E of B | No direct B-C link | Used to fix D relative to B |
| C is W of D | C could be E or W of B | Narrows C's position relative to D |
| E is S of C | No direct B-C link | Links E and C vertically |
| E is SW of A | Implies C is W of A (since E is S of C) | Crucial link: C is W of A |
| A is N of B & C is W of A | Implies C is W of B | Consistent with C being W of D if C is W of B |
| If C is W of B | B is E of C | Final relative position |
Problems involving relative directions test your ability to interpret and combine directional clues to establish spatial relationships. Here are some tips:
Which of the following statement is sufficient to find shortest distance between points M and J?
I. J & P (19m), P % N (22m), N @ O (25m)
II. P & Q (27m), N % P (20m), O @ N (22m), O # J (18m)
Which of the following statement is sufficient to prove B * RT?
I. F # H (17m), F & E (28m), D % E (17m)
II. D @ C (20m), B % C (17m)
If J @ K % M % L # W, How far is W with respect to J?
If M % N @ O $ P, in which direction is P with respect to M?
If U % V # W # R % S, then which of the following is definitely true?