Who said the following? "Discursive practices are not purely and simply modes of
manufacture of discourse. They take shape in technical ensembles. in institutions. in
behavioral schemes. in types of transmission and dissemination. In pedagogical forms that
both impose and maintain them"
Michael Foucault
The quote, "Discursive practices are not purely and simply modes of manufacture of discourse. They take shape in technical ensembles. in institutions. in behavioral schemes. in types of transmission and dissemination. In pedagogical forms that both impose and maintain them," is a famous articulation from the work of Michael Foucault. It highlights his view that discourse is not just language or text, but is deeply embedded in social structures and power relations.
For Michael Foucault, discursive practices are the sets of rules, often unstated, that determine what can be said, by whom, under what conditions, and with what effects within a particular field or historical period. They are more than just saying things; they are ways of doing things with words and through specific social mechanisms.
The quote explicitly mentions several elements where discursive practices take shape, reinforcing Foucault's complex understanding of how discourse functions:
| Element from Quote | Foucaultian Interpretation |
|---|---|
| Technical ensembles | Refers to technologies, tools, and systems used to produce and circulate discourse (e.g., printing press, media, digital platforms). |
| Institutions | Organizations (like schools, hospitals, prisons, legal systems) that define rules and contexts for discourse and wield power through it. |
| Behavioral schemes | The normalized actions and conduct associated with specific discourses and power relations. |
| Types of transmission and dissemination | How discourse is spread and communicated, influencing its reach and impact. |
| Pedagogical forms | Educational systems and teaching methods that transmit established knowledge and norms, thereby imposing and maintaining specific discursive practices. |
This perspective moves beyond viewing discourse as mere communication to seeing it as a fundamental part of how power operates and shapes reality in a society. Foucault's work often explored how these discursive practices evolved over time in areas like madness, punishment, and sexuality.
Michael Foucault is renowned for his analysis of the relationship between power, knowledge, and discourse. Concepts like "discursive practices," "power/knowledge," and the role of institutions (like the asylum, clinic, or prison) in shaping what can be known and said are central to his philosophical project. The specific phrasing about discourse taking shape within technical ensembles, institutions, and pedagogical forms strongly aligns with his methodology and key arguments found in works like The Archaeology of Knowledge or Discipline and Punish.
Other theorists like Roland Barthes (known for semiology and mythology), Homi K. Bhabha (postcolonial theory, hybridity), and Gayathri Chakravorty Spivak (postcolonial studies, deconstruction, subaltern studies) have different primary areas of focus and different ways of conceptualizing language, power, and social structures, making Foucault the most fitting attribution for this particular quote on discursive practices.
| Concept | Attributed Author | Key Idea |
|---|---|---|
| Discursive Practices Quote | Michael Foucault | Discourse is shaped by institutions, technology, behavior, and education, not just language itself. |
Foucault's theory of discourse is a cornerstone of post-structuralist thought. He argued that discourse is not just a way of expressing ideas, but a system that produces knowledge and meaning. Discourses have rules of formation that govern what statements are possible and meaningful within a specific historical and social context. These rules are tied to power relations, meaning that certain discourses gain authority and exclude others. His work demonstrated how different discourses (e.g., medical discourse, legal discourse) construct their objects of study (e.g., the patient, the criminal) and establish regimes of truth that shape social practices and individual subjectivities. Understanding Foucault's concept of discursive practices is key to grasping his broader critiques of power and social control.
Match List-I with List-II:
| List-I | List-II |
|---|---|
| (A) Meghe Dhaka Tara | (I) Govind Nihalani |
| (B) Garam Hawa | (II) Habib Tanvir |
| (C) Tamas | (III) Ritvik Ghatak |
| (D) Jis Lahore Nahin Vekhya O Jamya-e-nai | (IV) M.S. Sathyu |
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Which of the following statements are correct?
(A) Mahabharata has over 1,00,000 verses.
(B) Mahabharata was written by Valmiki.
(C) V.S. Sukthankar is associated with the critical edition of Mahabharata.
(D) The critical edition of Mahabharata took 47 years to complete.
(E) The critical edition of Mahabharata ran into over 13,000 pages.
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Who wrote the essay "Naipaul's India and Mine" (1984) as a reply to V.S. Naipaul's An Area of Darkness ?
Identify the one that has not been paired correctly.
Which of the following Articles of the Indian Constitution made the provision for use of English, alongside Hindi, for official purposes, for fifteen years?