All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Who of the following is being talked about in the following lines?

"... you seem to understand me,

By each at once her choppy finger laying

Upon her skinny lips: you should be women,

And yet your beards forbid me to interpret

That you are so."

The correct answer is

The witches in Macbeth

Analyzing the Quote and Identifying the Characters

The question asks to identify the characters being described in the provided lines from a play. Let's break down the quote and analyze the key descriptions:

  • "you seem to understand me": The speaker feels these characters comprehend what is being said.
  • "By each at once her choppy finger laying Upon her skinny lips": This imagery describes their physical appearance and a gesture suggesting silence or a strange, unsettling nature. "Choppy" suggests rough or wrinkled, and "skinny lips" imply thinness.
  • "you should be women, And yet your beards forbid me to interpret That you are so": This is a crucial description. The characters appear to be women, but their beards make their gender uncertain or contradictory.

Now let's consider the options provided and see which group of characters fits this description:

Evaluating the Options

Let's look at each option in relation to the quote:

  • The plebeians in Coriolanus: Plebeians are common people. While they might react to a speaker, there is nothing in their typical depiction in Shakespeare (or specifically in Coriolanus) that would describe them as having "choppy fingers," "skinny lips," or being women with "beards." This option does not fit the physical description.
  • The sisters in King Lear: Goneril, Regan, and Cordelia are King Lear's daughters. They are clearly identified as women and, while their actions and characters are significant, there is absolutely no physical description of them having "beards" or such unsettling features as "choppy fingers" and "skinny lips." This option does not fit the physical description.
  • The witches in Macbeth: The Witches (often referred to as the Weird Sisters) in Shakespeare's Macbeth are famously described in ambiguous and unsettling terms. In Act 1, Scene 3, when Banquo first encounters them alongside Macbeth, he says lines very similar to the quote provided. He notes their strange appearance, questioning if they are mortal, and specifically mentions their appearance seeming like women ("you should be women") but being contradicted by their facial hair ("your beards forbid me"). This description perfectly matches the quote.
  • The players in Hamlet: The players are actors who perform in Shakespeare's Hamlet. They are a troupe of travelling actors. There is no description of them in the play that remotely matches the physical characteristics mentioned in the quote, such as "choppy fingers," "skinny lips," or women with "beards." This option is clearly incorrect.

Conclusion

Based on the distinct physical description provided in the quote, particularly the unsettling combination of appearing as women yet having beards and other strange features, the characters being discussed are undeniably the Witches from Shakespeare's Macbeth. The lines are spoken by Banquo upon first seeing them.

Description Point How it relates to The Witches in Macbeth
"...you seem to understand me..." The Witches show unnatural knowledge and prophecy.
"...By each at once her choppy finger laying Upon her skinny lips..." Fits their eerie, unsettling, non-human appearance and secretive nature.
"...you should be women, And yet your beards forbid me to interpret That you are so." This is a direct and famous description of the Witches' ambiguous and masculine-like features.

Revision Table: Key Characters in Shakespearean Plays

Play Key Characters Mentioned in Options Brief Description/Relevance
Coriolanus Plebeians Common citizens; often portrayed as a fickle mob. No physical description matches the quote.
King Lear Sisters (Goneril, Regan, Cordelia) Daughters of King Lear; central to the plot involving betrayal and loyalty. Clearly women, no mention of beards.
Macbeth Witches (Weird Sisters) Supernatural beings who deliver prophecies to Macbeth and Banquo; described as strange and ambiguously gendered with beards.
Hamlet Players A group of actors hired to perform; used by Hamlet to test Claudius's guilt. No physical description matches the quote.

Additional Information: The Witches in Macbeth

The Witches in Macbeth are pivotal characters, driving the plot forward through their prophecies. Their appearance is deliberately strange and unsettling, blurring the lines between genders and the human and the supernatural. This ambiguity contributes significantly to the play's atmosphere of darkness, confusion, and moral uncertainty. Their description is one of the most memorable in Shakespearean literature, making the lines in the quote highly recognizable to anyone familiar with the play.

The line is spoken by Banquo in Act 1 Scene 3, just after he and Macbeth encounter the Witches for the first time. His reaction highlights their bizarre appearance and raises questions about their true nature, which is central to understanding their role as instruments of fate or agents of temptation in the play.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Literature

  1. Match List-I with List-II:

    List-IList-II
    (A) Meghe Dhaka Tara(I) Govind Nihalani
    (B) Garam Hawa(II) Habib Tanvir
    (C) Tamas(III) Ritvik Ghatak
    (D) Jis Lahore Nahin Vekhya O Jamya-e-nai(IV) M.S. Sathyu

    Choose the correct answer from the options given below: 

  2. Which of the following statements are correct?

    (A) Mahabharata has over 1,00,000 verses. 

    (B) Mahabharata was written by Valmiki. 

    (C) V.S. Sukthankar is associated with the critical edition of Mahabharata. 

    (D) The critical edition of Mahabharata took 47 years to complete. 

    (E) The critical edition of Mahabharata ran into over 13,000 pages. 

    Choose the correct answer from the options given below :

  3. Who wrote the essay "Naipaul's India and Mine" (1984) as a reply to V.S. Naipaul's An Area of Darkness ?

  4. Identify the one that has not been paired correctly.

  5. Which of the following Articles of the Indian Constitution made the provision for use of English, alongside Hindi, for official purposes, for fifteen years?

Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App