Who among the following propounded the monotheistic theory of sovereignty?
Austin
Understanding the Monotheistic Theory of Sovereignty
The question asks about the scholar who is known for propounding the monotheistic theory of sovereignty. Sovereignty is a core concept in political science, referring to the supreme power or authority within a territory.
What is the Monotheistic Theory of Sovereignty?
The monotheistic, or monistic, theory of sovereignty posits that sovereign power is unified, indivisible, absolute, and illimitable. This view holds that there is a single, supreme authority within the state that cannot be legally bound or limited.
Austin's Contribution to Monistic Sovereignty
John Austin, a prominent British jurist and philosopher, is widely recognized as a key proponent of the monistic or monotheistic theory of sovereignty. His work, particularly "The Province of Jurisprudence Determined," lays out his analytical approach to law and sovereignty.
According to Austin's view:
- Sovereignty resides in a determinate human superior who receives habitual obedience from the bulk of a given society.
- This superior is not in a habit of obedience to a like superior.
- Commands issued by this sovereign backed by sanctions constitute positive law.
- The sovereign's power is absolute and illimitable by law.
Austin's theory is often associated with the command theory of law, where law is seen as the command of the sovereign.
Analysis of Options
- Austin: John Austin is indeed the scholar most famously associated with the monistic or monotheistic theory of sovereignty, describing it as a unified, absolute, and indivisible power residing in a single entity.
- Awk: This does not correspond to a recognized major figure in political or legal philosophy regarding sovereignty.
- Aquinas: Thomas Aquinas was a medieval philosopher and theologian. While he discussed political authority and law, his views are distinct from Austin's modern concept of absolute, indivisible sovereignty in a secular state.
- Maitland: Frederic William Maitland was a British historian and legal scholar who was critical of Austin's theory of sovereignty, particularly from a historical and common law perspective. He is associated with pluralistic views rather than monistic.
Based on the analysis, John Austin is the correct answer as he is the principal propounder of the monotheistic (monistic) theory of sovereignty in the context of modern political thought.
| Feature | Monistic (Austin) | Pluralistic (Maitland, Laski) |
|---|---|---|
| Nature of Sovereignty | Unified, Absolute, Indivisible | Divided, Limited, Shared among groups |
| Location of Sovereignty | Single determinate superior | Multiple associations and groups |
| Legal Limit | No legal limit on sovereign | Sovereignty is limited by law, custom, and other associations |
| Key Proponents | John Austin, Thomas Hobbes | F.W. Maitland, H.J. Laski, G.D.H. Cole |
Revision Table: Key Concepts
| Term | Definition | Associated Scholar(s) |
|---|---|---|
| Sovereignty | Supreme power or authority within a territory. | Bodin, Hobbes, Austin, Rousseau, etc. |
| Monistic Sovereignty | Theory that sovereignty is a single, absolute, indivisible power. | Austin, Hobbes |
| Pluralistic Sovereignty | Theory that sovereignty is divided or shared among multiple associations. | Maitland, Laski |
| Command Theory of Law | Law as the command of a sovereign, backed by sanctions. | Austin |
Additional Information: Evolution of Sovereignty Concept
The concept of sovereignty has evolved significantly over time. Jean Bodin is often credited with formally introducing the concept in the 16th century. Thomas Hobbes further developed the idea of absolute sovereignty in the context of the social contract. John Austin provided a precise legal definition focusing on a determinate human superior. In the 20th century, the rise of international law and the recognition of fundamental rights have led to further debates and challenges to the idea of absolute and unlimited state sovereignty.
Important Questions from Political Theory
Match List - I with List - II and select the correct answer using the codes given below :
List - I List - II a. Hegel i. Juridical b. Austin ii. Sociological c. Maclver iii. Descriptive d. Garner iv. Metaphysical "All within the State, none outside the State, none against the State". This statement points to a
Legal sovereign is the certain authority which can legitimately express the highest orders of the State, who can disregard divine law, moral principle and public opinion. This definition is given by
Who has written that, "it is better to be a Socrates dissatisfied than a pig satisfied"?
The nature has placed mankind in subjection to two masters, pleasure and misery. This idea was given by
