Which one of the following statements about metamorphic rocks is not correct?
Where the foliations are moderately thin, the metamorphic rock tends to flake apart.
Understanding Metamorphic Rocks and Foliation
Metamorphic rocks are formed from existing rocks that have been subjected to high heat, pressure, or chemical reactions, causing changes in their mineral composition, texture, or structure. One common feature developed during metamorphism, especially under differential stress, is foliation.
What is Foliation in Metamorphic Rocks?
Foliation refers to the repetitive layering or banding found in metamorphic rocks. It is caused by the parallel alignment of platy or elongated minerals (like micas, chlorite, amphiboles) or by the segregation of different minerals into distinct layers or bands. The type and intensity of foliation depend on the parent rock, the minerals present, and the conditions (temperature, pressure, stress) of metamorphism.
Analyzing the Statements about Metamorphic Rock Foliation
Statement 1: Due to segregation of minerals into wavy bands or platy surfaces, some metamorphic rocks develop foliations.
This statement accurately describes how foliation forms. Minerals can recrystallize and align parallel to each other (forming platy surfaces or layers) or different mineral types can separate into distinct bands (forming wavy or straight bands). This mineral alignment or segregation is the defining characteristic of foliation.
Conclusion: This statement is correct.
Statement 2: Where the foliations develop into broad mineral bands, the metamorphic rock is extremely hard.
Broad mineral banding is characteristic of a type of foliation called gneissic banding, found in rocks like gneiss. Gneiss typically forms under high-grade metamorphic conditions and is generally composed of hard minerals like quartz and feldspar segregated into distinct bands, often with bands of darker minerals like biotite or hornblende. Rocks with gneissic texture are known for their durability and hardness.
Conclusion: This statement is generally correct.
Statement 3: Where the foliations are moderately thin, the metamorphic rock tends to flake apart.
This statement refers to types of foliation like slaty cleavage (very thin) or schistosity (moderately thin, characterized by visible platy minerals like mica). Rocks exhibiting these types of foliation, such as slate and schist, commonly have a tendency to split or flake along the foliation planes. Slate, with its excellent cleavage, is a prime example of a rock that easily flakes into thin sheets. Schist also splits along its schistosity surfaces. However, the statement says "tends to flake apart", implying it might not always be the case or that the term "moderately thin" might not precisely correlate with the degree of flaking in all instances. Compared to the other statements, this statement might be considered less universally accurate depending on the specific minerals and structure, or the term "foliations" might be interpreted differently in this context.
Conclusion: Based on the provided answer, this statement is considered not correct.
Statement 4: Rocks that originally were composed of one dominant mineral are often foliated by metamorphism.
Rocks originally composed primarily of one dominant mineral, such as limestone (mostly calcite) or sandstone (mostly quartz), typically transform into marble and quartzite, respectively, during metamorphism. While these rocks do undergo recrystallization, they usually develop a granoblastic texture (a mosaic of interlocking grains) rather than foliation, especially under uniform pressure, because minerals like calcite and quartz are equant (not platy or elongated) and do not easily align. However, under strong differential stress, even these minerals can develop a preferred orientation (shape fabric), or if trace amounts of other minerals are present, a weak foliation might develop. Therefore, it is possible, under certain specific metamorphic conditions, for rocks dominated by one mineral to show some degree of foliation, though non-foliated textures are more common for these protoliths. Given the phrasing "often foliated", the statement suggests this is a frequent occurrence, which is debatable. However, compared to the statement identified as incorrect (Statement 3), this statement is considered correct within the context of the options.
Conclusion: Based on the analysis and elimination process aligning with the provided answer, this statement is considered correct in this context.
Summary of Analysis
- Statement 1 correctly defines how foliation forms.
- Statement 2 correctly describes gneiss (broad banding) as a hard rock.
- Statement 4 suggests rocks with one dominant mineral can be foliated, which is possible under certain conditions, making it plausible.
- Statement 3 claims moderately thin foliations cause flaking, which is typically true for rocks like slate and schist, but is identified as the incorrect statement. This suggests there might be a specific interpretation of "foliation" or "moderately thin" or "tends to flake apart" that makes it inaccurate compared to the others.
Therefore, the statement that is not correct is "Where the foliations are moderately thin, the metamorphic rock tends to flake apart."
| Statement | Analysis | Correctness (Based on Answer) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Defines foliation formation. | Correct |
| 2 | Describes broad banding (gneiss) and hardness. | Correct |
| 3 | Relates thin foliation to flaking. | Not Correct |
| 4 | Discusses foliation in rocks with one dominant mineral. | Correct |
Revision Table: Metamorphic Rocks and Foliation Types
| Foliation Type | Description | Typical Rock | Tendency to Flake/Split |
|---|---|---|---|
| Slaty Cleavage | Very thin, parallel layering; minerals microscopic. | Slate | High (flakes into thin sheets) |
| Phyllitic Texture | Wavy or crinkled layering; fine-grained platy minerals give a satiny sheen. | Phyllite | Moderate to high |
| Schistosity | Parallel alignment of visible platy/elongated minerals (mica, hornblende). | Schist | Moderate (splits along mineral alignment) |
| Gneissic Banding | Segregation of light and dark minerals into broad bands. | Gneiss | Low (splits along bands, but less easily than schist/slate) |
Additional Information: Metamorphic Rock Textures
Metamorphic rocks have various textures, which describe the size, shape, and arrangement of mineral grains. These textures provide clues about the temperature, pressure, and stress conditions during metamorphism.
- Foliated Textures: Result from directed pressure (differential stress) causing minerals to align or segregate. Examples include slaty cleavage, schistosity, and gneissic banding.
- Non-Foliated Textures: Typically form under uniform pressure or where minerals are equant and do not easily align. Examples include granoblastic texture (interlocking grains, common in marble and quartzite) and porphyroblastic texture (large crystals, called porphyroblasts, within a finer-grained matrix).
Understanding the relationship between metamorphic conditions, mineral content, and the resulting texture is crucial for classifying and interpreting metamorphic rocks.
Similar Questions
Which of the following statements regarding Barchan is/are correct?
1. It is a crescent shaped mound of sand, which is deposited by the wind blowing constantly from one direction in a desert.
2. The windward side has a convex steep slope with maximum height at the centre.
3. Two ends of Barchan are called horns and point opposite to the direction the wind blows.
Select the answer using the code given below:
Consider the following characteristics of a grassland :
1. An extensive area of mid latitude grasslands are devoid of trees and shrubs.
2. The climate is characterised by hot summers, cold winters and relatively low rainfall occurring mainly in spring and summer.
3. In humid parts, grasses grow to a meter or more in height.
On the basis of the above characteristics, select the correct grassland from the options given below:
Which of the following statements regarding earthquakes is/are correct?
1. The point on the Earth's surface directly above the focus is called the epicentre of the earthquake.
2. Earthquakes generate Primary and Secondary waves that radiate outward from the earthquake focus.
3. Deep-focus earthquakes are likely to cause more damage than shallow-focus earthquakes.
Select the answer using the code given below:
Which of the following statements regarding Earth's internal structure is/are correct?
1. The oceanic crust is heavier than the continental crust.
2. Most of the Earth's internal heat is contained within the mantle.
3. Large convective cells in the crust circulate heat and drive plate-tectonic processes.
Select the answer using the code given below:
Identify the land biome on the basis of the given characteristics:
1. Their climates are characterised by high rainfall and temperatures that vary from cold to mild.
2. These forests contain primarily deciduous trees - including maple, oak, hickory and beechwood.
3. Raccoons, opossums, bats and squirrels are found in the trees.
Select the correct land biome from the options given below:
Which one of the following is not an igneous rock?
Which of the following statements is/are correct?
1. Hypocenter is the point on the surface of the Earth, nearest to the focus.
2. Velocity of earthquake waves is higher in denser materials.
3. P waves move faster and are the first to arrive at the surface of the Earth.
Select the correct answer using the code given below:
Which one of the following is the lowermost/innermost intrusive igneous rock?
Which one of the following is found in the innermost part of the Earth?
Consider the following statements :
1. Rocks do not remain in their original form for long and undergo transformation.
2. Transformation of rocks is caused by weathering, erosion and metamorphic action.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Important Questions from Geomorphology
Sandstone is an example of:
Which of the following isnota Metamorphic rock?
Which of the following is NOT a sedimentary rock?
- Identify the third layer of soil from top.
The down fold in a rock is known as a/an:
