All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Which of the following statements about The New Model Unions is/are correct?

1. The New Model Unions were formed in the 1850s

2. The New Model Unions were formed in the 1880s

3. The New Model Unions comprised a Labour Party idea

4. The New Model Unions excluded women in the 1920s

Select the correct answer using the code given below:

This question was previously asked in
NDA II 2019 GAT Previous Year Paper (17-Nov-2019)
The correct answer is

1

Understanding The New Model Unions

The question asks about the characteristics and formation period of The New Model Unions. Let's analyze each statement provided to determine its accuracy based on historical context.

We will examine each statement carefully:

  • Statement 1: The New Model Unions were formed in the 1850s.
  • Statement 2: The New Model Unions were formed in the 1880s.
  • Statement 3: The New Model Unions comprised a Labour Party idea.
  • Statement 4: The New Model Unions excluded women in the 1920s.

Analysis of Statement 1: Formation in the 1850s

The New Model Unions emerged primarily in the 1850s. A key example is the formation of the Amalgamated Society of Engineers (ASE) in 1851. These unions were a departure from earlier, more militant forms of unionism. They focused on skilled workers, sought legal recognition, built up financial reserves to provide benefits (like sickness or unemployment pay) to members, and preferred negotiation and arbitration over strikes. Their formation period is strongly associated with the 1850s and early 1860s.

Based on historical evidence, statement 1 is correct.

Analysis of Statement 2: Formation in the 1880s

The 1880s saw the rise of what are sometimes referred to as the "New Unionism," which was different from the New Model Unions. New Unionism in the 1880s focused more on organizing unskilled and semi-skilled workers, who were largely excluded by the New Model Unions. Therefore, The New Model Unions were formed significantly earlier than the 1880s.

Based on historical evidence, statement 2 is incorrect.

Analysis of Statement 3: Comprised a Labour Party Idea

The New Model Unions focused primarily on improving the working conditions, wages, and status of their skilled members through collective bargaining, mutual insurance, and lobbying for legal changes related to trade union rights. While individual trade unionists and leaders later played roles in the formation and development of the Labour Party (which officially emerged around 1900), The New Model Unions themselves were not formed around the concept of creating a political party like the Labour Party. Their focus was on industrial and legal aspects of trade unionism, not establishing a broad-based political platform for labour.

Based on historical evidence, statement 3 is incorrect.

Analysis of Statement 4: Excluded Women in the 1920s

The New Model Unions, in their prime period of the 1850s-1870s, predominantly represented skilled male workers. They generally excluded women, as women were largely concentrated in different, often lower-paid or unskilled, industries and were not traditionally part of the craft-based unions. While exclusion was characteristic of their earlier period, stating they "excluded women in the 1920s" is slightly complex. By the 1920s, the trade union landscape had changed significantly, with the rise of New Unionism and general unions which did include women. Some of the old New Model Unions might have continued discriminatory practices, but the statement is too broad and places the exclusion specifically in the 1920s as a defining characteristic of these unions at that time, which is less accurate than describing their exclusionary practices in their formative years.

However, the primary characteristic of New Model Unions regarding membership was indeed the exclusion of unskilled workers, which disproportionately affected women. While the 1920s saw changes, the legacy of exclusion remained. But comparing this statement's certainty with statement 1, statement 1 is definitively correct.

Considering the context and the options provided, statement 1 is the most accurate and universally accepted historical fact among the given choices regarding The New Model Unions.

Conclusion

Based on the analysis of each statement:

  • Statement 1: Correct.
  • Statement 2: Incorrect.
  • Statement 3: Incorrect.
  • Statement 4: Partially true historically about their nature, but the specific timeframe of the 1920s makes it less definitively correct than statement 1 in describing their primary characteristics.

Only statement 1 is historically accurate regarding the formation period of The New Model Unions.

Revision Table: Key Facts about New Model Unions

Characteristic Description
Formation Period Primarily 1850s and early 1860s
Membership Mainly skilled craft workers (e.g., engineers, builders, printers)
Goals Improve wages, working conditions, status; provide mutual benefits (sickness, unemployment)
Methods Collective bargaining, negotiation, arbitration, financial reserves, lobbying
Contrast with Earlier Unions Less militant, more bureaucratic, sought respectability and legal status
Contrast with New Unionism (1880s) Excluded unskilled/semi-skilled workers and largely women; higher membership fees

Additional Information on Trade Union Development

The development of trade unions in the UK involved several phases:

  • Early Unions (pre-1850s): Often localized, craft-based, sometimes secret societies, facing legal restrictions and repression.
  • New Model Unions (1850s-1870s): Characterized by stability, financial strength, focus on skilled workers, and pursuit of legal recognition (e.g., the Trade Union Act 1871).
  • New Unionism (1880s onwards): Expansion of unionism to include unskilled and semi-skilled workers (e.g., dockers, matchgirls), often more confrontational tactics.
  • Rise of General Unions and Industrial Unions: Further consolidation and organization across different trades and industries in the late 19th and 20th centuries.
  • Political Representation: Growing involvement in politics, leading to the formation of the Labour Party as the political voice of the working class and trade unions.

The New Model Unions were a crucial step in establishing stable, recognized trade unionism, though their exclusive nature limited their reach compared to later developments.

Was this answer helpful?

Similar Questions

  1. Consider the following statements concerning the Russian Revolution:

    1) The Bolsheviks believed that in a repressive society like Tsarist Russia, the party should be disciplined and should control the number of its members.

    2) The Mensheviks believed that the party should be opened to all (as in Germany).

    Which of the statement/s given above is/are correct?
  2. Which of the following was/were among the decisions taken by the First Continental Congress held in Philadelphia in September 1774?

    1) It rejected a plan for a colonial union under the British authority.

    2) It drew up a statement of grievances.

    3) It agreed upon a scheme to stop trade between the Colonies and England.

    Select the correct answer using the code given below:
  3. Consider the following statements concerning the American War of Independence:

    1) The Americans raised the slogan, 'No taxation without representation'.

    2) The American merchants resorted to the boycott of the British products.

    Select the correct answer using the code given below:
  4. Which country among the following was not a part of the Third Coalition against Napoleon?

  5. The Truman Doctrine of 1947 was announced to achieve which one of the following?

  6. Which one of the following statements about the Olympe de Gouges (1748 – 1793) is correct?

  7. Who among the following built a model steam engine in 1698 called “Miner’s Friend” to drain mines?

  8. Which one of the following statements about Renaissance Humanist culture is NOT true?

  9. The following 6(Six) items consist of two statements, Statement I and Statement II. Examine these two statements carefully and select the correct answer using the code given below.

    Statement I: Chartism was the political reform campaign for democratic rights which swept over Britain between 1838 and 1848.

    Statement II: The trade union movement declined by the 1830s as it failed to fulfil the aspirations of the working class.

  10. The treaty of Schonbrunn (1809) was signed after which one of the following battles?


Important Questions from World History

  1. Observe the natural disasters impact on human loss and choose the countries with highest casualties in descending order:
    A. Bangladesh
    B. China
    C. Peru
    D. Soviet Union
    Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
  2. Examine the top industrial disaster which occurred between 1945 to 1990 and choose the place/countries of highest deaths in ascending order.
    A. Cali, Colombia
    B. Salang Pass, Afghanistan
    C. Bhopal, India
    D. Kyshtym, USSR
    Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
  3. Match the LIST-I with LIST-II
     

    LIST-ILIST-II
    A. The Religious SchoolsI. United Kingdom
    B. Nordic Folk High SchoolsII. USA
    C. The Chautauqua MovementIII. Denmark
    D. The Workers' Education MovementIV. England


    Choose the correct answer from the options given below:

  4. Who is known as the father of 'Cultural Hegemony'?
  5. The term ' genocide' was coined by 

Need Expert Advice?
Test Series
NDA img
Defence
NDA 2026 Mock Test Series (Latest Pattern)
526 Tests 1 Tests Free
1196 Attempts
4.7(162)
English, Hindi

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App