All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Which of the following services is jointly controlled by both the Union and State Governments?

The correct answer is
Indian Administrative Service

Jointly Controlled Services Explained

This question requires us to identify a specific service within India's administrative framework that operates under the shared authority of both the central (Union) government and the various State governments. This type of service reflects India's federal structure, where powers are distributed between the centre and the states.

Analyzing Government Service Control

Let's examine each option to understand its control mechanism:

  • State Medical Service: Services like the State Medical Service are generally established and managed by individual State Governments. While national health policies exist, the direct administrative control, recruitment, and deployment fall under the state's domain.
  • Indian Economic Service: This is classified as a Central Service. Officers are recruited through competitive examinations conducted by the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) and are employed by various ministries and departments of the Union Government. State governments do not share administrative control over this service.
  • Central Engineering Service: Similar to the Indian Economic Service, the Central Engineering Service comprises engineers working for the Union Government. They are managed and controlled exclusively by the central government departments and agencies.
  • Indian Administrative Service (IAS): The Indian Administrative Service is one of the three main 'All India Services' (the others being the Indian Police Service and Indian Forest Service). The defining characteristic of All India Services is that they are created by an Act of Parliament (Union Government) but are rendered to the States. Officers are recruited centrally by the UPSC. While these officers work within the state cadres and are primarily under the administrative control of the State Government they are posted to, the Union Government retains significant control over matters like framing recruitment rules, conditions of service, and disciplinary actions. This dual aspect of recruitment by the Union and service under the States, with joint oversight on rules and policy, signifies joint control.

Identifying the Jointly Controlled Service

Based on the analysis, the Indian Administrative Service (IAS) stands out as the service jointly controlled by both the Union and State Governments. Its unique position as an 'All India Service' necessitates a cooperative framework between the central and state administrations for effective functioning and governance across the country.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Centre-State Relations

  1. Which of the following criteria are specified for granting Special Category Status to States in India?
    1. Hilly and difficult terrain
    2. Economic and infrastructural backwardness
    3. Strategic coastal zone
    4. Sizeable share of tribal population
    Select the answer using the code given below :
  2. Who has the power to give directions to the State Government to ensure compliance with Union laws?
  3. Which of the following subjects was moved from the State List to the Concurrent List by the $42^{nd}$ Amendment Act?
  4. The Inter-State Council is constituted under which Article?
  5. Which Article of the Indian Constitution deals with the distribution of legislative powers between the Union and the States?
Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App