All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Which of the following is/are true regarding scientific investigations ?
(a) Results are not influenced by procedure.
(b) Social context may influence conclusions in any investigation.
(c) Data and evidence are same.
(d) There is no universal scientific method.

The correct answer is
(b) and (d)

Scientific Investigations: Evaluating Statements

This section explains the key aspects of scientific investigations and evaluates the truthfulness of the statements provided in the question.

Statement Analysis

  • Statement (a): Results are not influenced by procedure.

    This statement is false. The way a scientific experiment or investigation is conducted (the procedure) directly affects the results obtained. Different procedures can lead to different data, even when studying the same topic. For example, measuring temperature with a thermometer partially submerged versus fully submerged in a liquid will yield different results.

  • Statement (b): Social context may influence conclusions in any investigation.

    This statement is true. Science operates within society. Factors like cultural values, funding priorities, political climates, and societal needs can shape which research questions are asked, how research is conducted, how data is interpreted, and which conclusions are accepted or emphasized. This influence is often subtle but can be significant.

  • Statement (c): Data and evidence are same.

    This statement is false. Data refers to the raw facts, observations, or measurements collected during an investigation. Evidence is the interpretation of that data, used to support or refute a hypothesis or claim. Data needs to be processed and analyzed to become meaningful evidence.

  • Statement (d): There is no universal scientific method.

    This statement is true. While the scientific process generally involves steps like observation, hypothesis formation, experimentation, and analysis, there isn't a single, rigid, step-by-step method that applies universally to all scientific fields and inquiries. The specific approach often varies depending on the discipline (e.g., astronomy vs. biology) and the nature of the problem being investigated.

Conclusion on True Statements

Based on the analysis above, statements (b) and (d) are considered true regarding scientific investigations.

Evaluating the Options

Let's examine the given options based on our analysis:

  • Option 1: (a) and (b) - Incorrect because (a) is false.
  • Option 2: (b) and (d) - Correct because both (b) and (d) are true.
  • Option 3: (a) and (c) - Incorrect because both (a) and (c) are false.
  • Option 4: (c) and (d) - Incorrect because (c) is false.

Therefore, the correct choice highlights that the social context can influence conclusions and that there isn't one single universal scientific method.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Nature and Structure of Science - Teaching

  1. Which of the following is not the logical necessity of experimental work in science?
  2. In the scientific method, a hypothesis is best described as a:

  3. In a controlled experiment, the variable that is deliberately manipulated to test its effect on the outcome is called the :

  4. Scientific findings are considered reliable primarily because they are :

  5. Match List I with List II :
    List I
    (Value)
    List II
    (Result)
    (a) Patience(i) In gathering & rewarding data
    (b) Perseverance(ii) Willingness to share equipments
    (c) Cooperation(iii) Experiments on repeated basis till results are achieved
    (d) Honesty(iv) In waiting for results of experiments

    Choose the most appropriate answer from the options given below :
Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App