All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Direction: Study the following information carefully and answer the questions based on it.

Seven persons P, Q, R, X, T, A, K go to gym on 7 different days of the week from Sunday to Saturday but not necessarily in the same order.

R goes to the gym on the weekend. K goes to the gym after X but before Q. Number of persons goes to the gym before A is the same as the number of Persons goes to the gym after Q. K and X do not go to the gym on Wednesday. Q goes to the gym a few days after A. Only one person goes to the gym between R and X. P likes to go to the gym on weekdays.

Which of the following combination is incorrect?

This question was previously asked in
ESIC UDC Mains MBT (30 Apr 2022)
The correct answer is

Q - Saturday

The problem requires us to determine the correct gym schedule for seven people (P, Q, R, X, T, A, K) across seven days of the week (Sunday to Saturday) based on a set of clues, and then identify the incorrect combination among the given options.

Analyzing the Clues and Constraints

Let's break down the information provided:

  • People: P, Q, R, X, T, A, K
  • Days: Sunday (1), Monday (2), Tuesday (3), Wednesday (4), Thursday (5), Friday (6), Saturday (7)
  • Clue 1: R goes to the gym on the weekend (Sunday or Saturday).
  • Clue 2: K goes after X, and K goes before Q. This implies the order is X ... K ... Q in terms of days.
  • Clue 3 & 5: The number of people before A equals the number of people after Q. Also, Q goes after A. Let $D_A$ be the day number for A and $D_Q$ be the day number for Q.
    • Number before A = $D_A - 1$
    • Number after Q = $7 - D_Q$
    • From Clue 3: $D_A - 1 = 7 - D_Q \implies D_A + D_Q = 8$.
    • From Clue 5: $D_Q > D_A$.
    Possible (A, Q) pairs satisfying $D_A + D_Q = 8$ and $D_Q > D_A$:
    • If $D_A=1$ (Sun), $D_Q=7$ (Sat)
    • If $D_A=2$ (Mon), $D_Q=6$ (Fri)
    • If $D_A=3$ (Tue), $D_Q=5$ (Thu)
  • Clue 4: K and X do not go to the gym on Wednesday (Day 4).
  • Clue 6: Only one person goes to the gym between R and X. This means their day numbers differ by 2, i.e., $|D_R - D_X| = 2$.
  • Clue 7: P likes to go to the gym on weekdays (Monday to Friday).

Step-by-Step Deduction

Step 1: Determine possible positions for R and X using Clues 1 and 6.

R must be on Sunday (1) or Saturday (7).

  • Case 1: R is on Sunday (1). Using $|D_R - D_X| = 2$, we get $|1 - D_X| = 2$. This means $D_X$ must be 3 (Tuesday). This is valid as X is not on Wednesday.
  • Case 2: R is on Saturday (7). Using $|D_R - D_X| = 2$, we get $|7 - D_X| = 2$. This means $D_X$ must be 5 (Thursday). This is valid as X is not on Wednesday.

So, the possible pairs for (R, X) are (Sun, Tue) or (Sat, Thu).

Step 2: Evaluate the possible (A, Q) pairs with the (R, X) placements.

Possible (A, Q) pairs are: (A=1, Q=7), (A=2, Q=6), (A=3, Q=5).

Evaluating Case 1 (R=Sun(1), X=Tue(3)):

  • Subcase 1a: Test (A=1, Q=7). This conflicts because R is already assigned to Sunday (1). Invalid.
  • Subcase 1b: Test (A=2, Q=6). So, A = Monday (2), Q = Friday (6).
    • We have R=Sun(1), A=Mon(2), X=Tue(3), Q=Fri(6).
    • Now use Clue 2 (X ... K ... Q): X is Tue(3), Q is Fri(6). K must be between Tuesday and Friday. Possible days for K are Wednesday (4) or Thursday (5).
    • Use Clue 4 (K not on Wednesday): K cannot be on Wednesday (4). Therefore, K must be on Thursday (5).
    • Current assignment: R=Sun(1), A=Mon(2), X=Tue(3), K=Thu(5), Q=Fri(6).
    • Days remaining: Wednesday (4) and Saturday (7). People remaining: P and T.
    • Use Clue 7 (P on weekdays): P must be on a weekday. The remaining weekdays are Wednesday (4). So, P = Wed(4).
    • The last person T must be on the remaining day, Saturday (7).
    • Final Schedule Check: Sun(R), Mon(A), Tue(X), Wed(P), Thu(K), Fri(Q), Sat(T).
      • R weekend: Yes (Sun).
      • X..K..Q order: Tue..Thu..Fri. Yes.
      • Before A = After Q: $D_A=2$, $D_Q=6$. Before A = 1 (Sun). After Q = 1 (Sat). Yes.
      • K,X not Wed: K=Thu, X=Tue. Yes.
      • Q after A: $D_Q=6 > D_A=2$. Yes.
      • 1 between R & X: R=Sun(1), X=Tue(3). Mon(2) is between. Yes.
      • P weekdays: P=Wed(4). Yes.
      This schedule is valid.
  • Subcase 1c: Test (A=3, Q=5). So, A = Tuesday (3), Q = Thursday (5). This conflicts because X is already assigned to Tuesday (3). Invalid.

Evaluating Case 2 (R=Sat(7), X=Thu(5)):

  • Subcase 2a: Test (A=1, Q=7). A = Sunday (1), Q = Saturday (7). This conflicts because R is already assigned to Saturday (7). Invalid.
  • Subcase 2b: Test (A=2, Q=6). A = Monday (2), Q = Friday (6).
    • We have R=Sat(7), X=Thu(5), A=Mon(2), Q=Fri(6).
    • Use Clue 2 (X ... K ... Q): X is Thu(5), Q is Fri(6). K must be between Thursday and Friday. There is no day between Thursday and Friday. Impossible to place K. Invalid.
  • Subcase 2c: Test (A=3, Q=5). A = Tuesday (3), Q = Thursday (5). This conflicts because X is already assigned to Thursday (5). Invalid.

Since Case 2 yields no valid schedules, the only possible schedule is the one derived from Case 1b.

Final Schedule and Incorrect Combination

The only valid schedule determined is:

Day Person
Sunday R
Monday A
Tuesday X
Wednesday P
Thursday K
Friday Q
Saturday T

Now, let's check the given options against this schedule:

  • 1. A - Monday: This combination is present in the schedule. Correct.
  • 2. Q - Saturday: This combination is NOT present in the schedule (Q is on Friday). Incorrect.
  • 3. K - Thursday: This combination is present in the schedule. Correct.
  • 4. R - Sunday: This combination is present in the schedule. Correct.
  • 5. Q - Friday: This combination is present in the schedule. Correct.

The question asks for the incorrect combination. Based on our derived schedule, the combination 'Q - Saturday' is incorrect.

Was this answer helpful?

Similar Questions

  1. Who goes to the gym a day before P?


Important Questions from Puzzle

  1. If ‘<’ stands for ‘−’, ‘>’ stands for ‘+’, ‘=’ stands for ‘×’ and ‘$’ stands for ‘÷’, what will come in place of the question mark (?) in the following equation? 

    31 > 81 $ 9 < 7 = ?

  2. If ‘A’ stands for ‘÷’, ‘B’ stands for ‘×’, ‘C’ stands for ‘+’ and ‘D’ stands for ‘−’, what will come in place of the question mark (?) in the following equation? 

    35 B 4 C 6 D 84 A 14 = ?

  3. This question is based on the five, three-digit numbers given below.

    (Left) 468 429 517 371 386 (Right)

    Example: 697 – First digit = 6, second digit = 9 and third digit = 7. (Note: All operations to be done from left to right.)

    What will be the resultant if the second digit of the highest number is multiplied with the second digit of the lowest number?

  4. This question is based on the five, three-digit numbers given below.

    (Left) 897 687 819 623 832 (Right)

    Example: 697 – First digit = 6, second digit = 9 and third digit = 7. (Note: All operations to be done from left to right.)

    What will be the resultant if the second digit of the highest number is added to the third digit of the lowest number?

  5. This question is based on the five, three-digit numbers given below.

    (Left) 138 436 253 173 752 (Right)

    (Example- 697 – First digit = 6, second digit = 9 and third digit = 7) (NOTE: All operations to be done from left to right.)

    What will be the resultant if the third digit of the lowest number is added to the second digit of the highest number?

Need Expert Advice?
Test Series
ESIC UDC img
Banking
ESIC UDC 2025 Mock Test Series
98 Tests 4 Tests Free
440 Attempts
4.5(2)
English, Hindi

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App