All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Read the passage carefully and answer questions according to the passage:
Aristotle and Horace are our classical texts for genre theory. From them, we think of tragedy and epic as the characteristic (as well as the two major) kinds. But Aristotle at least is also aware of other and more fundamental distinctions - between drama, epic, and lyric. Most modern literary theory would be inclined to scrap the prose-poetry distinction and then to divide imaginative literature (Dichtung) into fiction (novel, short story, epic), drama (whether in prose or verse), and poetry (centering on what corresponds to the ancient 'lyric poetry'). Vietor suggests, quite properly, that the term 'genre' ought not to be used both for these three more-or-less ultimate categories and may be used for such historical kinds as tragedy and comedy; and we agree that it should be applied to the latter - the historical kinds. A term for the former is difficult to manage - perhaps not often, in practice, needed. The three major kinds are already, by Plato and Aristotle, distinguished according to 'manner of imitation' (or 'representation'): lyric poetry is the poet's own persona; in epic poetry (or the novel) the poet partly speaks in his own person, as narrator, and partly makes his characters speak in direct discourse (mixed narrative); in drama, the poet disappears behind his cast of characters.

What does Vietor argue against using the term 'genre' for both ultimate literary categories and historical kinds?

The correct answer is
Because historical kinds such as tragedy and comedy, should be the only focus of genre classification.

Vietor's Argument on Genre Classification

The question asks about Vietor's argument regarding the use of the term 'genre', based on the provided passage. The passage discusses classical genre theory from Aristotle and Horace, distinguishing between ultimate literary categories like drama, epic, and lyric, and historical kinds such as tragedy and comedy.

Analyzing the Passage on Genre Theory

According to the passage, Vietor suggests that the term 'genre' should not be applied to both the fundamental categories (drama, epic, lyric) and the historical kinds (tragedy, comedy) simultaneously. The passage explicitly states agreement with Vietor that the term 'genre' "should be applied to the latter - the historical kinds." This indicates a preference or a more specific application of the term 'genre' to these historical forms.

Evaluating the Options Based on the Passage

Let's examine each option in light of the passage's information:

  • Option 1: Focus on Historical Kinds

    This option states: "Because historical kinds such as tragedy and comedy, should be the only focus of genre classification." The passage supports the idea that the term 'genre' should be applied to historical kinds like tragedy and comedy. While the passage doesn't use the exact word "only," the emphasis on applying 'genre' specifically to these historical kinds, and not to both ultimate and historical categories, strongly implies that these historical kinds are the primary or intended focus for genre classification in this context.

  • Option 2: Relevance of Ultimate Categories

    This option suggests: "Because the ultimate categories, such as lyric, epic and drama, are no longer relevant." The passage identifies lyric, epic, and drama as "three more-or-less ultimate categories" distinguished by Plato and Aristotle. It does not state that these categories are irrelevant; rather, it differentiates how the term 'genre' should be applied concerning them versus historical kinds. Therefore, this option is not supported by the text.

  • Option 3: Exclusion of Prose and Poetry

    This option claims: "Because prose and poetry should not be classified under any genre system." The passage mentions modern literary theory "would be inclined to scrap the prose-poetry distinction" and proceeds to discuss divisions including fiction (novel, short story, epic) and poetry (lyric poetry). This indicates these forms are considered within classification systems, not excluded entirely. Thus, this option contradicts the passage's implications.

  • Option 4: Original Application of Genre

    This option proposes: "Because the term 'genre' originally applied only to prose narratives." The passage refers to classical texts by Aristotle and Horace, discussing drama, epic, and lyric poetry. These are not exclusively prose narratives, suggesting the term 'genre' had a broader application in classical theory than just prose narratives. The passage does not provide information to support this statement as Vietor's reason.

Based on the analysis, Option 1 aligns best with Vietor's suggestion as interpreted and agreed upon in the passage, emphasizing the application of the term 'genre' to historical kinds like tragedy and comedy.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Analytical Decision Making

  1. The two types of imagination as discussed by French psychologist Ribot are:
  2. In what way does epic poetry differ from drama in terms of representation, as stated in the passage?
  3. How does the concept of enonciation relate to the ideological function of parody?
  4. Direction: There are five doctors 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5; four engineers G, H, K and L; and six teachers M, N, O, P, Q and R. Among these some teams are to be selected. Of these 1, 2, G, H, O, P, Q are females and the rest are males. The formation of the teams is subject to the following conditions: Wherever there is a male doctor, there will be a female teacher. 
    Wherever there is a male engineer, there will be a female doctor. 
    There shall not be more than two male teachers in any team. 
    If the team consists of two doctors, two female teachers and two engineers, all the following teams are possible except

  5. "Mirtunjay is planning to buy a test series for the CAT exam. Following are the criteria of selection for any online portal fixed by him: 
    1. Must contain 25 Full-length mock tests. 
    2. Must contain last 8 years previous year papers. 
    3. Must have more than 10,000 practice questions on the portal, 
    4. If any portal satisfies all the above criteria except (1) but has more than 20 mock tests and more than 5 previous year papers then he will keep that shortlisted. 
    5. If any portal satisfies all the above criteria except (3) but has more than 8000 practice questions and recorded class videos then he will ask his mentor. "Let's crack CAT" is providing online test series for CAT. It is providing 18 mock tests and 5 previous years' Paper. It is also providing 12000 practice questions. 
    Which of the following is correct for the selection of the online portal given above?"

Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App