Question
The Five Judges Constitution Bench held that 'Imparting Education cannot be treated as a Trade or Business' in which of the following cases ?
The correct answer is
P.A. Inamdar Case
P.A. Inamdar Case: Education Ruling
The question refers to a significant judgment by a Five Judges Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court concerning the nature of imparting education.
Key Ruling Analysis
- The Constitution Bench ruling established that 'Imparting Education cannot be treated as a Trade or Business'.
- This principle was laid down in the case of P.A. Inamdar vs. State of Maharashtra.
- The judgment clarified that while educational institutions may operate commercially, the core activity of imparting knowledge and education itself is a charitable function and not a trade.
- This ruling helps in distinguishing between the non-profit objective of education and the potential commercial activities undertaken by institutions.
Therefore, the P.A. Inamdar Case is the correct reference for the stated principle.
Was this answer helpful?
Important Questions from Fundamental Rights
- The 25th Amendment curtailed the right to property by amending which Article of Indian Constitution?
- Which of the following Fundamental Rights is guaranteed under Article 14 of the Indian Constitution?
- Which Article of the Indian Constitution directs the State to promote the welfare of the people?
Which of the following Articles was introduced by the $86^{th}$ Amendment to impose a duty on parents to educate children?
- Which Article of the Indian Constitution deals with the impeachment procedure of the President?
Need Expert Advice?
