All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Read the following statements in the context of Laws and theories in Science :
S1: Laws are generalisation statement whereas theories are explanations.
S2: Laws are very old and theories are contemporary.
S3: Laws can't be changed whereas theories are subject to change.

The correct answer is
S1 is true; S2 and S3 are false

Analyzing Scientific Laws and Theories

This question requires evaluating three statements about the nature of scientific laws and theories. Let's break down each statement to determine its accuracy.

Statement S1: Laws are Generalizations, Theories are Explanations

This statement accurately describes a key distinction between scientific laws and theories.

  • Scientific Laws: These are typically concise statements, often expressed as mathematical equations, that describe a fundamental relationship or regularity observed in nature. They describe *what* happens under specific conditions but don't necessarily explain *why* it happens. For example, Newton's Law of Universal Gravitation describes the gravitational force between two objects but doesn't explain the mechanism behind gravity itself.
  • Scientific Theories: These are well-substantiated explanations of some aspect of the natural world, based on a body of facts that have been repeatedly confirmed through observation and experiment. Theories explain *why* phenomena occur. For instance, Einstein's theory of general relativity provides an explanation for gravity as a consequence of the curvature of spacetime.

Therefore, statement S1 is considered true.

Statement S2: Laws are Old, Theories are Contemporary

This statement is inaccurate. The age of a law or theory does not define its nature.

  • Many scientific laws, like those proposed by Isaac Newton, are centuries old, yet they remain fundamental to physics.
  • Conversely, many theories are quite contemporary, such as theories related to dark energy or quantum computing, while others, like the theory of evolution, are much older but still foundational and continuously refined.
  • Both laws and theories can originate at different points in scientific history.

Therefore, statement S2 is considered false.

Statement S3: Laws Can't Be Changed, Theories Are Subject to Change

This statement presents a common misconception and is largely false.

  • Scientific Laws: While laws represent well-established observations, they are not necessarily immutable. If new evidence consistently contradicts a law or reveals limitations to its applicability, the law may be refined, modified, or restricted to specific conditions. For example, Newtonian mechanics works well for everyday speeds but is superseded by relativity at speeds approaching the speed of light.
  • Scientific Theories: Theories are inherently dynamic. They are models built to explain observations, and they are constantly tested against new evidence. If evidence challenges a theory, it must be revised or replaced by a better explanation. This is a strength of the scientific process, not a weakness.

Both laws and theories evolve with scientific understanding. While theories might be seen as more readily modified or replaced due to their explanatory nature, even established laws can be refined or shown to be approximations under certain conditions. Thus, the rigid distinction made in S3 is incorrect.

Therefore, statement S3 is considered false.

Conclusion

Based on the analysis:

  • S1 is true.
  • S2 is false.
  • S3 is false.

This matches the option where S1 is true, and S2 and S3 are false.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Nature and Structure of Science - Teaching

  1. Which of the following is not the logical necessity of experimental work in science?
  2. In the scientific method, a hypothesis is best described as a:

  3. In a controlled experiment, the variable that is deliberately manipulated to test its effect on the outcome is called the :

  4. Scientific findings are considered reliable primarily because they are :

  5. Match List I with List II :
    List I
    (Value)
    List II
    (Result)
    (a) Patience(i) In gathering & rewarding data
    (b) Perseverance(ii) Willingness to share equipments
    (c) Cooperation(iii) Experiments on repeated basis till results are achieved
    (d) Honesty(iv) In waiting for results of experiments

    Choose the most appropriate answer from the options given below :
Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App