Pointing towards a girl, Shilpa said, "She is daughter of my husband's wife". How is Shilpa 's son related to that girl?
Brother
Understanding the Blood Relation Problem
This question asks us to figure out the relationship between two people based on a statement made by a third person. These are classic blood relation puzzles. We need to carefully break down the statement made by Shilpa to understand who the girl is.
Breaking Down Shilpa's Statement
Shilpa says, "She is daughter of my husband's wife". Let's analyze this part by part:
- "My husband's wife": When Shilpa says "my husband's wife", she is referring to herself, as she is the wife of her husband.
- "She is daughter of [my husband's wife]": Substituting "my husband's wife" with "Shilpa", the statement becomes "She is daughter of Shilpa".
Therefore, the girl Shilpa is pointing towards is Shilpa's daughter.
Determining the Relationship between Shilpa's Son and the Girl
We have established that the girl is Shilpa's daughter. The question asks how Shilpa's son is related to that girl.
- Shilpa's son and Shilpa's daughter are siblings.
- A son is the brother of his sister.
So, Shilpa's son is the brother of Shilpa's daughter (the girl).
Final Answer Conclusion
Based on the analysis of Shilpa's statement, the girl is Shilpa's daughter. Shilpa's son is therefore the brother of her daughter.
The relationship of Shilpa's son to that girl is Brother.
Revision Table: Key Blood Relation Terms
| Relation | Description |
|---|---|
| Father's father | Grandfather |
| Mother's mother | Grandmother |
| Father's mother | Grandmother |
| Mother's father | Grandfather |
| Father's son | Brother (if speaking from perspective of another son/daughter) or Son |
| Father's daughter | Sister (if speaking from perspective of another son/daughter) or Daughter |
| Husband's wife | Self |
| Wife's husband | Self |
Additional Information on Blood Relation Puzzles
Solving blood relation problems often involves creating a mental or written family tree or diagram based on the given statements. Key strategies include:
- Identify the speaker and the person being referred to.
- Break down complex statements into smaller, more manageable parts.
- Work backwards or forwards from known relationships.
- Recognize common phrases like "husband's wife" or "wife's husband" which refer to the speaker themselves.
- Practice with various types of statements to become familiar with different relational terms.
These questions test your ability to logically deduce relationships within a family structure.
Important Questions from General Blood Relation Problems
A is the husband of B, C is the mother-in-law of B, D is the father of A, E is the mother of D, F is the mother of C and G. If H is the father of D, then what is the relation of H with E?
Neeraj pointed at a photo of a lady and said, "She is the daughter of my paternal grandfather's only son. What is the relation of Neeraj with the lady in the photo?
If my sister's mother-in-law's only son is Devika's father, how is Devika's paternal grandfather related to my sister?
Pointing towards a boy, Ranjita said, “He is my husband's father-in-law's only daughter's son's father's only sister's son”. How is that boy's mother related to Ranjita's husband?
If Samaira is the daughter of my father's mother's only son, how is Samaira related to me?
