List - 1
(Philosopher)List - II
(Primal matter)α. Thales (i) Fire b. Anaxagoras (ii) Nous C. Anaximenes (iii) Water d. Heraclitus (iv) Air
This question requires matching prominent early Greek philosophers with their distinct ideas about the fundamental substance or 'primal matter' (arche) from which everything originates. Let's break down each philosopher's core concept:
Thales of Miletus, considered one of the first Western philosophers, proposed that Water is the arche. He likely observed that water is essential for life, exists in different states (solid, liquid, gas), and is abundant.
Anaxagoras introduced a different concept. Instead of a single primal substance, he suggested that reality consists of an infinite number of tiny, distinct "seeds" or "homoeomeries," each containing portions of all things. However, he also proposed Nous (Mind or Intellect) as the cosmic principle that initiated motion and order among these seeds, organizing the cosmos.
Anaximenes, a student of Anaximander (who proposed 'apeiron' or the indefinite), believed that Air was the arche. He explained how different substances arise from air through processes of rarefaction (becoming thinner, like fire) and condensation (becoming denser, like wind, cloud, water, earth, and stone).
Heraclitus of Ephesus famously asserted that Fire is the fundamental element. He saw the universe as constantly in flux, driven by conflict and change, with fire representing this dynamic, transformative nature. For him, fire was not just a substance but also a symbol of this ceaseless becoming.
Based on the explanations above, we can correctly match the philosophers (List I) with their proposed primal matter (List II):
| List I (Philosopher) | List II (Primal Matter) |
| α. Thales | (iii) Water |
| b. Anaxagoras | (ii) Nous |
| c. Anaximenes | (iv) Air |
| d. Heraclitus | (i) Fire |
Therefore, the correct matching is α-iii, b-ii, c-iv, d-i.
| List - 1 | List - II |
| α. Refutation of innate ideas | (i) Descartes |
| b. Refutation of matter | (ii) Locke |
| C. Acceptance of innate ideas | (iii) Berkeley |
| d. Refutation of Self | (iv) Hume |