List - I List - II (a) No one has any other 'right' than always to do his duty. (i) Gray (b) 'Right' is power over an object which by means of this right he subjected to will of the person enjoying the right. (ii) Holland (c) Legal right means, ""A capacity residing in one man of controlling with the assent and assistance of the state, the acts of the other"". (iii) Duguit (d) 'Right' is not the interest by itself but it is a mean by which enjoyment of interest is secured. (iv) Pachta
Matching Legal Rights Definitions
This question requires matching various definitions and conceptualizations of 'legal right' presented in List - I with the corresponding jurists or thinkers mentioned in List - II.
Correct Matches Explained
The correct pairings, as indicated by the provided answer, are detailed below:
- (a) Duty-Centric Right: The statement "No one has any other 'right' than always to do his duty" is matched with (iv) Pachta. This highlights a perspective where rights are intrinsically linked to fulfilling one's duties.
- (b) Power Over Object: The definition "'Right' is power over an object which by means of this right he subjected to will of the person enjoying the right" is matched with (iii) Duguit. This emphasizes the control and power a right-holder exercises over a specific object.
- (c) State-Assisted Capacity: The definition "Legal right means, 'A capacity residing in one man of controlling with the assent and assistance of the state, the acts of the other'" is matched with (i) Gray. This defines a legal right as a state-backed ability to influence or control the actions of others.
- (d) Interest Securing Mean: The concept "'Right' is not the interest by itself but it is a mean by which enjoyment of interest is secured" is matched with (ii) Holland. This views a right primarily as an instrument or mechanism used to protect and ensure the enjoyment of underlying interests.
Final Answer Verification
Based on the analysis of each statement and its corresponding match:
- (a) corresponds to (iv)
- (b) corresponds to (iii)
- (c) corresponds to (i)
- (d) corresponds to (ii)
Therefore, the correct option is (a)-(iv), (b)-(iii), (c)-(i), (d)-(ii).
Important Questions from Jurisprudence
- Which one of the following Jurists asserts that 'Law and morality are complementary and supplementary to each other'?
- Salmond enumerates five characteristics of legal rights. Four such characteristics are
(a) Subject of right
(b) Object of right
(c) Content of right
(d) Title of right
The fifth characteristic is: - Who among the following said that there is in essence, no difference between the legal personality of a company and that of an individual?
- Which of the following statements is NOT correct in regard to distinction between Civil and Criminal liability?
- Which of the following could be considered to be advantages of Legislation over Precedent?
(a) Abrogative capability
(b) Fore knowledge
(c) Prospective application
(d) Systematic arrangement
Choose the correction option:
