In the following question, out of the four alternatives, select the alternative which will improve the bracketed part of the sentence. In case no improvement is needed, select "no improvement". By then running water and electricity (had arrive), making the well and the lamp post redundant.
had arrived
Analyzing the Sentence and Identifying the Grammatical Error
The given sentence is: "By then running water and electricity (had arrive), making the well and the lamp post redundant."
We need to examine the bracketed part "(had arrive)" and determine if it is grammatically correct or if it requires improvement. The phrase "By then" indicates a point in the past. This suggests the use of a past tense or past perfect tense to describe an action that happened or was completed by that time.
The structure "had + verb" is used to form the past perfect tense. A fundamental rule of English grammar is that the verb following "had" (or "has", "have") must be in its past participle form (V3). The base form of the verb is V1, the simple past is V2, and the past participle is V3.
- Base form (V1): arrive
- Simple past (V2): arrived
- Past participle (V3): arrived
In the bracketed part, we have "had arrive". Here, "arrive" is the base form (V1). This is incorrect because "had" requires the past participle form (V3), which is "arrived". Therefore, "had arrive" is grammatically incorrect.
Evaluating the Options for Sentence Improvement
Let's look at the provided options to find the correct way to phrase the bracketed part.
- had arriving: This option uses the V-ing form ("arriving") after "had". The V-ing form is typically used with forms of "be" to create continuous tenses (e.g., "were arriving") or as a gerund or participle. It is not used directly after "had" to form the past perfect tense. So, this option is incorrect.
- had arrived: This option uses "had" followed by "arrived". "Arrived" is the past participle (V3) of "arrive". This structure, "had + V3", correctly forms the past perfect tense. The past perfect tense is appropriate here because "By then" indicates an action ("running water and electricity coming") that was completed before a specific time in the past. So, this option appears correct.
- arriving: This option uses only the V-ing form. Standing alone, "arriving" cannot function as the main verb in this context with "had". While a V-ing form can be part of a participial phrase or a continuous tense, neither applies correctly here to replace "had arrive". So, this option is incorrect.
- no improvement: As established earlier, "had arrive" is grammatically incorrect because "arrive" is not the past participle required after "had". Therefore, improvement is needed, making this option incorrect.
Confirming the Correct Improvement: Had Arrived
Based on the analysis of the grammatical rules for the past perfect tense and the context provided by "By then", the correct form to use after "had" is the past participle "arrived". The phrase "had arrived" correctly conveys that the action of running water and electricity coming had been completed by that specific point in the past ("By then").
The corrected sentence using option 2 would be: "By then running water and electricity had arrived, making the well and the lamp post redundant." This sentence is grammatically sound and makes logical sense.
| Original Phrase | Analysis | Correct Form |
|---|---|---|
| (had arrive) | Incorrect. "arrive" is V1. "had" requires V3. | had arrived |
Revision Table: Verb Forms with 'Had'
| Verb Tense/Structure | Auxiliary Verb(s) | Main Verb Form | Example (with 'arrive') |
|---|---|---|---|
| Simple Past | - | V2 (Past Simple) | They arrived yesterday. |
| Past Perfect | had | V3 (Past Participle) | They had arrived before we left. |
| Present Perfect | have/has | V3 (Past Participle) | They have arrived. |
Additional Information: Understanding the Past Perfect Tense
The past perfect tense is formed using had + past participle (V3). It is used to talk about an action that happened before another action or time in the past. The structure is:
Subject + had + Past Participle (V3) + ...
Examples:
- She had finished her homework before she went out. (Finishing happened before going out, both in the past).
- By the time we arrived, the show had already started. (Starting happened before arriving, both in the past).
In the given sentence, "By then" signifies a specific past time (the point when running water and electricity arrived). The arrival happened before that point. So, the past perfect tense ("had arrived") is the correct choice to indicate this completion before the specified past time.
The sentence "By then running water and electricity had arrived, making the well and the lamp post redundant" means that by a certain time in the past, running water and electricity were already available, and as a result, the old methods (well and lamp post) were no longer needed.
Important Questions from Phrase Replacement
In the following question, out of the four alternatives, select the alternative which will improve the underlined part of the sentence. In case no improvement is needed, select “No improvement”
My old teacher gave many poor students money in spite of he was poor.
In the following question, out of the four alternatives, select the alternative which will improve the underlined part of the sentence. In case no improvement is needed, select “No improvement”.
You should to read the newspaper regularly if you want to be well-informed.
In the following question, out of the four alternatives, select the alternative which will improve the underlined part of the sentence. In case no improvement is needed, select “No improvement”.
If he had listening to me he would not have got lost.
In the following question, out of the four alternatives, select the alternative which will improve the underlined part of the sentence. In case no improvement is needed, select “No improvement”
He asked for a bank loan also he didn't have sufficient resources.
In the following question, out of the four alternatives, select the alternative which will improve the underlined part of the sentence. In case no improvement is needed, select “No improvement”.
I went to the shop to buy some stationeries .
