Assertion (A) : Voices in the City, although its canvas is large, the details fuller and diction richer, is nevertheless less satisfying than Cry, the Peacock.
Reason (R) : The reason is that Voices in the City is not contained by a single sensibility like Maya's in Cry, the Peacock.
In the light of the above statements, choose the most appropriate answer from the options given below:
Evaluating Assertion and Reason on Anita Desai's Novels
This section analyzes the given Assertion (A) and Reason (R) regarding Anita Desai's novels, 'Voices in the City' and 'Cry, the Peacock', to determine their correctness and the relationship between them.
Assertion (A) Analysis
Assertion (A) states that 'Voices in the City', despite its larger scope, detailed descriptions, and richer language, is less satisfying than 'Cry, the Peacock'.
- This is a subjective literary judgment but reflects a common critical viewpoint. Many critics find 'Cry, the Peacock' more impactful due to its intense focus on Maya's psychological state.
- 'Voices in the City' explores multiple characters and their internal conflicts, which can sometimes dilute the emotional intensity compared to a singular, focused narrative.
- Therefore, the assertion presents a valid critical perspective that can be considered correct in the context of literary analysis.
Reason (R) Analysis
Reason (R) explains that 'Voices in the City' is less satisfying because it is not confined by a single sensibility, unlike Maya's in 'Cry, the Peacock'.
- 'Cry, the Peacock' is renowned for its deep exploration of Maya's alienation, existential dread, and psychological breakdown, making her internal world the central driving force. This is what is meant by being "contained by a single sensibility".
- 'Voices in the City' presents a more complex tapestry of characters (N immo, Monisha, Saïla, Aunt Usha), each with distinct psychological struggles and perspectives. The narrative weaves these different sensibilities together.
- The absence of a singular, dominant sensibility in 'Voices in the City' contributes to its broader canvas but potentially less focused emotional impact, as suggested by the reason. Thus, this reason is also considered correct.
Relationship Between Assertion and Reason
The reason provided directly addresses why the assertion might be true.
- The lack of a singular, unified sensibility in 'Voices in the City' (Reason R) explains why its expansive details and richer diction might lead to a less satisfying experience for readers compared to the tightly focused, psychologically intense narrative driven by Maya's sensibility in 'Cry, the Peacock' (Assertion A).
- Therefore, Reason (R) correctly explains Assertion (A).
Conclusion
Based on the analysis, both Assertion (A) and Reason (R) are correct statements, and Reason (R) provides a valid explanation for Assertion (A).
Important Questions from Mixed Topic (CUET PG)
- Who was the founder of Bolshevik Communist party?
- What is the key guide to statecraft in the realist tradition?
- Chronologically arrange the events in the Cold War period.
A. Berlin Wall is constructed
B. Communist China joins the UN
C. Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia
D. Berlin Blockade
Choose the correct answer from the options given below: Morgenthau's principles of political realism are:
A. Politics is rooted in permanent and unchanging human nature which is basically self centred, self-regarding and self-interested
B. Politics is an autonomous sphere of action and cannot therefore be reduced to morals
C. International Politics is an arena of conflicting self-interests
D. The ethics of international relations is situational ethics which is very different from private morality
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:Who among the following political thinkers consider the anarchical self help system to be a compelling factor for States to maximise their relative power positions?
