All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Given below are two statements, one is labelled as Assertion A and the other is labelled as Reason R

Assertion A: Democracy has become a global force; while it has become widespread, but all is not well with this political system and it has got into some difficulties almost everywhere

Reason R: For its failure, it is not the institution itself that is to be blamed; it is the way it has worked or the way its working has been distorted and manipulated by those in power

In light of the above statements, choose the correct answer from the options given below

The correct answer is

Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A

Analyzing the Assertion and Reason on Democracy Challenges

Let's carefully examine the given Assertion (A) and Reason (R) regarding the state of democracy globally.

Examining Assertion A: Democracy as a Global Force with Difficulties

Assertion A states: "Democracy has become a global force; while it has become widespread, but all is not well with this political system and it has got into some difficulties almost everywhere."

  • The first part, "Democracy has become a global force," is generally accepted as true. Over the past few decades, the number of democratic countries has significantly increased, making democracy a prevalent form of government worldwide.
  • The second part, "all is not well with this political system and it has got into some difficulties almost everywhere," is also widely supported by observations and studies of contemporary democracies. Many democracies face issues such as political polarization, corruption, economic inequality, declining public trust in institutions, and challenges to democratic norms and processes. These difficulties are indeed observed in various democratic nations across the globe.

Based on this analysis, Assertion A appears to be a true statement.

Examining Reason R: Blaming Implementation, Not the Institution

Reason R states: "For its failure, it is not the institution itself that is to be blamed; it is the way it has worked or the way its working has been distorted and manipulated by those in power."

  • Reason R offers an explanation for the "difficulties" or "failure" mentioned in Assertion A. It argues that the problems with democracy are not inherent flaws in the democratic system itself (like the principles of voting, representation, rights) but rather stem from how democracy is *practiced* or *implemented*.
  • It points to the "way it has worked" or how it has been "distorted and manipulated by those in power." This suggests that the actions of political leaders, institutions failing to function correctly, or external pressures are the causes of democratic difficulties, rather than democracy's core structure being inherently faulty. This perspective is a common analytical viewpoint when discussing challenges in established democracies.

Based on this analysis, Reason R also appears to be a true statement, offering a plausible explanation for democratic difficulties.

Evaluating the Relationship between A and R

Now we need to determine if Reason R is the correct explanation for Assertion A.

  • Assertion A says democracy faces difficulties globally.
  • Reason R says these difficulties arise because of how democracy is implemented and manipulated, not because of the democratic institution itself.

If democracy faces difficulties (A) *because* its working is distorted and manipulated (R), then R directly explains *why* Assertion A is true. Reason R provides the causal link for the difficulties mentioned in Assertion A. The difficulties (A) are a consequence of the factors described in R (poor implementation, manipulation). Therefore, Reason R serves as a correct explanation for Assertion A.

Conclusion

Both Assertion A and Reason R are true statements, and Reason R provides a valid explanation for the difficulties faced by democracy as described in Assertion A.

Therefore, the correct answer is that both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A.

Statement Evaluation Reasoning
Assertion A True Democracy is widespread but faces numerous challenges globally.
Reason R True Difficulties stem from implementation/manipulation, not the core system.
Relationship (R explains A) Yes Reason R provides a cause for the difficulties described in Assertion A.

Revision Table: Understanding Democracy's Challenges

This table helps summarize the key points about the Assertion and Reason.

Concept Description Relevance to Question
Global Democracy The spread of democratic systems across many countries. Assertion A mentions democracy as a global force.
Difficulties in Democracy Challenges faced by democratic nations (e.g., corruption, inequality, polarization). Assertion A states democracy faces difficulties almost everywhere.
Democratic Institution The fundamental principles and structure of democracy (e.g., voting, rule of law, rights). Reason R argues the institution itself is not to blame.
Implementation/Working of Democracy How democratic principles are put into practice, the actions of political actors, and the functioning of institutions. Reason R blames the "way it has worked" and "manipulation."

Additional Information: Causes of Democratic Difficulties

While Reason R points to implementation and manipulation, various factors contribute to the challenges facing contemporary democracies. Understanding these factors provides deeper insight into Assertion A.

  • Economic Factors: Rising inequality, economic stagnation, and job losses can fuel discontent and populism, challenging democratic stability.
  • Social Factors: Deep social divisions, identity politics, and cultural clashes can increase political polarization and make consensus difficult.
  • Technological Factors: The spread of misinformation and disinformation through social media can undermine informed public discourse and manipulate public opinion.
  • Institutional Weaknesses: Corruption, lack of transparency, and ineffective governance within democratic institutions can erode public trust.
  • External Influences: Interference from other states or non-state actors can destabilize democratic processes.
  • Leadership Issues: Leaders who undermine democratic norms, centralize power, or prioritize personal gain over public good contribute significantly to difficulties, aligning with Reason R's focus on manipulation.

These factors illustrate how the *working* of democracy and *manipulation* by actors within the system (as stated in Reason R) can lead to the widespread difficulties observed in democracies globally (as stated in Assertion A).

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Indian Democracy

  1. During the role of __________ the caste system in India suffered a severe shock in the villages

  2. Which one of the following is the one which exerts sufficient influence on government to be able to put pressure on behalf of its interests ?
  3. Who proposed reservation for lower caste during the Congress Committee's Adhiveshan(meeting) held at Kanchipuram ?
  4. Match the List - I with List - II

    List-1List - II
    (a) Deictic movements(1) Pacing motions
    (b) Spatial movements(2) Illustrating a verbal statement
    (c) Rhythmic movements(3) Depicting or outlining space
    (d) Emblematic movement(4) Pointing
Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App