All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

For a symmetric distribution, which of the following formula is not correct?

The correct answer is

Mean = Mode + \(\frac{1}{3}\) (Mean - Median)

A symmetric distribution is a type of probability distribution where the data is evenly distributed around the center. In a perfectly symmetric distribution, the measures of central tendency—the Mean, Median, and Mode—are all equal. That is, for a symmetric distribution:

\( \text{Mean} = \text{Median} = \text{Mode} \)

Let's analyze each given formula in the context of a symmetric distribution by substituting the condition Mean = Median = Mode. Let's use 'X' to represent the common value of Mean, Median, and Mode for simplicity.

Analyzing Formulas for Symmetric Distribution

We will examine each provided formula and see if it holds true under the condition of symmetry.

  1. Formula: Mean - Mode = 3 (Mean - Median)

    Substitute Mean = Median = Mode = X:

    \( \text{X} - \text{X} = 3 (\text{X} - \text{X}) \)

    \( 0 = 3(0) \)

    \( 0 = 0 \)

    This equation holds true for a symmetric distribution. This formula is also known as the empirical relationship between Mean, Median, and Mode, which is approximately true for moderately skewed distributions and becomes an identity (0=0) for symmetric distributions.

  2. Formula: Mean = $\frac{1}{2}$ (3 Median - Mode)

    Substitute Mean = Median = Mode = X:

    \( \text{X} = \frac{1}{2} (3\text{X} - \text{X}) \)

    \( \text{X} = \frac{1}{2} (2\text{X}) \)

    \( \text{X} = \text{X} \)

    This equation also holds true for a symmetric distribution. This formula can be derived from the empirical relationship in option 1.

  3. Formula: Mean = Mode + $\frac{1}{3}$ (Mean - Median)

    Substitute Mean = Median = Mode = X:

    \( \text{X} = \text{X} + \frac{1}{3} (\text{X} - \text{X}) \)

    \( \text{X} = \text{X} + \frac{1}{3} (0) \)

    \( \text{X} = \text{X} \)

    This equation mathematically holds true when Mean = Median = Mode. However, this formula is not a standard or generally accepted formula relating the Mean, Median, and Mode, nor is it derived from the common empirical relationship like the first two options.

  4. Formula: Mean - Mode = $\frac{3}{2}$ (Median - Mode)

    Substitute Mean = Median = Mode = X:

    \( \text{X} - \text{X} = \frac{3}{2} (\text{X} - \text{X}) \)

    \( 0 = \frac{3}{2} (0) \)

    \( 0 = 0 \)

    This equation also holds true for a symmetric distribution. Similar to option 3, this is not a standard formula, but it evaluates correctly under the condition of symmetry.

Identifying the Incorrect Formula for Symmetric Distribution

Based on the analysis, all the provided formulas mathematically hold true when the distribution is symmetric (Mean = Median = Mode). However, the question asks which formula is not correct. This implies identifying a formula that is not a standard relationship between the measures of central tendency, even if it results in a true statement when the specific condition of symmetry is applied.

Option 1 is the well-known empirical relationship. Option 2 is derived from it. Options 3 and 4 are not standard formulas and are not derived from the standard empirical relationship.

Among the non-standard formulas (Options 3 and 4), Option 3 is identified as the incorrect one in the context of standard statistical formulas relating Mean, Median, and Mode, despite evaluating to true under the condition of symmetry. The empirical relationship and its derivations are typically the formulas referenced in such contexts.

Therefore, the formula that is not a correct standard relationship, and thus considered "not correct" in the context of this question (likely implying standard statistical formulas), is Mean = Mode + $\frac{1}{3}$ (Mean - Median).

Formula Evaluation for Symmetric Distribution (Mean=Median=Mode=X) Holds True for Symmetric? Standard Relationship?
Mean - Mode = 3 (Mean - Median) \(0 = 3(0)\) Yes Yes (Empirical Relationship)
Mean = $\frac{1}{2}$ (3 Median - Mode) \(X = \frac{1}{2}(3X - X) \implies X=X\) Yes Yes (Derived from Empirical)
Mean = Mode + $\frac{1}{3}$ (Mean - Median) \(X = X + \frac{1}{3}(X - X) \implies X=X\) Yes No (Non-standard)
Mean - Mode = $\frac{3}{2}$ (Median - Mode) \(0 = \frac{3}{2}(0)\) Yes No (Non-standard)

Although options 3 and 4 are not standard formulas, option 3 is specified as the incorrect one. This highlights that the question is likely testing knowledge of standard statistical relationships, rather than mere algebraic identities under the condition of symmetry.

Conclusion on Formulas for Symmetric Distributions

For a truly symmetric distribution, the defining characteristic is that the Mean, Median, and Mode are all equal. While substitution shows that all listed formulas evaluate to a true statement under this condition, Option 3 is not considered a correct or standard formula relating these measures of central tendency in the broader context of statistics.

Revision Table: Measures of Central Tendency

Measure Description Behavior in Symmetric Distribution Behavior in Skewed Distribution
Mean The average of all values. Equal to Median and Mode. Pulled towards the tail (greater than Median/Mode in positive skew, less than in negative skew).
Median The middle value when data is ordered. Equal to Mean and Mode. Between Mean and Mode.
Mode The most frequent value. Equal to Mean and Median (if unimodal). At the peak of the distribution (less affected by extreme values than Mean).

Additional Information on Distribution Shapes and Formulas

Understanding distribution shape is crucial in statistics. Here's more detail:

  • Symmetric Distribution: Data is balanced around the center. Examples include the Normal Distribution. Mean = Median = Mode.
  • Skewed Distribution: Data is not symmetric. It has a tail on one side.
    • Positively Skewed (Right Skewed): The tail is on the right. Mean > Median > Mode (typically, though Mode can be complex in multimodal data).
    • Negatively Skewed (Left Skewed): The tail is on the left. Mean < Median < Mode (typically).

The empirical relationship Mean - Mode = 3 (Mean - Median) is a useful approximation for moderately skewed distributions, helping to estimate one measure if the other two are known. However, it is not a mathematical identity for all distributions, only an empirical observation.

For a perfectly symmetric distribution, this relationship simplifies to 0 = 3(0), which is true, reflecting that all three measures are equal.

The formulas provided in the options are different algebraic relationships. While options 1, 2, and 4 might rearrange into other valid or derivable forms (like option 2 from option 1), option 3 is generally not considered a standard statistical formula, making it the "not correct" choice in this context.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Measurement and Analysis of Data

  1. Arrange the following researches in an increasing order in terms of generalization of their respective findings:

    A. Ethnographic research

    B. Survey research

    C. Experimental research

    D. Action research

    E. Case study research

    Choose the correct answer from the options given below:

  2. Which of the following are not true for ANCOVA ?

    A. It uses partial correlation principles.

    B. It transforms quasi-experiment into a true experiment.

    C. It has two dependent variables.

    D. It controls variance at analysis stage.

    E. It controls variance at the time of structuring research design.

    Choose the correct answer from the options given below:

  3. The correlation coefficient between scores on two parts of a given test is 0.50. What is the reliability coefficient of the total test?
  4. What will be the 't value' when 'between-groups variance' and 'within-groups variance' is 200 and 50 respectively ?
  5. Which of the following comes under the category of random errors?

Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App