Read the following information and answer the given questions Following are the conditions for allotment of housing plots to a family at the time of allotment. A ) The family should have at least 4 members and only one married couple in It. B)The combined monthly family income should NOT be more than Rs.25,000 per month. C) No member of the family should have a criminal case against him/her D) No member of the family should have benefited from any other subsidy scheme. E) No member of the family should own any residential property. However, in case a family who fulfills all other criteria EXCEPT. 1) B above, and if the combined income includes pension, then the pension amount is deductible. 2) C above, and if the member has been released from imprisonment, then the case is referred to Central Police Station 3) E above, and if living in the same rented property for more than 7 years, then it will be treated as owned residential property. Based on these criteria and information provided below, decide the course of action in each case. You are NOT to assume anything.
Family B consists of the grandfather, his wife, his son, his daughter-in-law and his grandson. No members earn a living. The family survives on grandfather's Rs.30,000 per month pension. The family has no members who have a criminal case, they do not own a residential property and they have not received any other subsidy. They are living in a rented house since grandfather's marriage 30 years ago.
Reject plot
Analyzing Housing Plot Allotment Eligibility for Family B
This question requires us to carefully read the given conditions for housing plot allotment and apply them to the specific case of Family B. We must evaluate Family B against each rule and its exceptions to determine the correct course of action.
Housing Plot Allotment Conditions:
- A) The family should have at least 4 members and only one married couple in it.
- B) The combined monthly family income should NOT be more than \( \text{Rs.25,000} \) per month.
- C) No member of the family should have a criminal case against him/her.
- D) No member of the family should have benefited from any other subsidy scheme.
- E) No member of the family should own any residential property.
Exceptions to Conditions B, C, and E:
However, in case a family fulfills all other criteria EXCEPT:
- B above: If the combined income includes pension, then the pension amount is deductible.
- C above: If the member has been released from imprisonment, then the case is referred to Central Police Station.
- E above: If living in the same rented property for more than 7 years, then it will be treated as owned residential property.
Analysis of Family B's Eligibility:
Let's evaluate Family B based on each condition and the relevant exceptions.
- Condition A (Family Size and Couple): Family B consists of grandfather, his wife, his son, his daughter-in-law, and his grandson. This is a total of 5 members. There is one married couple (son and daughter-in-law). This fulfills Condition A (at least 4 members and only one married couple).
- Condition B (Income Limit): The combined monthly family income is the grandfather's pension of \( \text{Rs.30,000} \). This income is more than \( \text{Rs.25,000} \). So, Condition B is initially NOT fulfilled. However, Exception 1 applies as the income includes pension. Exception 1 states, "if the combined income includes pension, then the pension amount is deductible." Deducting the pension amount (\( \text{Rs.30,000} \)) from the total income (\( \text{Rs.30,000} \)) results in \( \text{Rs.0} \). Since \( \text{Rs.0} \) is NOT more than \( \text{Rs.25,000} \), Condition B is considered fulfilled after applying Exception 1.
- Condition C (Criminal Case): The information states that no member of the family has a criminal case. This fulfills Condition C.
- Condition D (Other Subsidy): The information states that they have not received any other subsidy. This fulfills Condition D.
- Condition E (Property Ownership): The information states they do not own a residential property. This initially fulfills Condition E. However, Exception 3 applies to Condition E and mentions living in rented property for more than 7 years. Family B has been living in a rented house for 30 years, which is more than 7 years. Exception 3 states, "if living in the same rented property for more than 7 years, then it will be treated as owned residential property." Based on this rule, despite not owning property, their long-term rental is treated as owned property. Therefore, Family B fails Condition E due to Exception 3.
Summary of Family B's Condition Status:
Let's summarize the status of each condition after applying the relevant exceptions:
- Condition A: Fulfilled
- Condition B: Fulfilled (after Exception 1)
- Condition C: Fulfilled
- Condition D: Fulfilled
- Condition E: Failed (due to Exception 3)
The rules state that a family must fulfill all conditions for allotment, unless a specific exception applies and leads to allotment or referral. Family B fails Condition E because their long-term rented property is treated as owned as per Exception 3. Since they fail a core eligibility condition (E) and the exception related to E (Exception 3) does not lead to them fulfilling the condition but rather causes them to fail it, they do not qualify for the plot allotment.
Conclusion:
Based on the analysis, Family B fails Condition E because their rented property is treated as owned property due to the long-term tenancy rule (Exception 3). Failing this condition makes them ineligible for the housing plot allotment.
Therefore, the correct course of action is to Reject plot.
| Condition | Requirement | Family B Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | ≥ 4 members, 1 married couple | Fulfilled | 5 members, 1 married couple |
| B | Income ≤ \( \text{Rs.25,000} \) | Fulfilled (via Exception 1) | Income \( \text{Rs.30,000} \) (pension). Pension deductible. Calc income \( \text{Rs.0} \). \( \text{Rs.0} \le \text{Rs.25,000} \) |
| C | No criminal case | Fulfilled | Stated no criminal case |
| D | No other subsidy | Fulfilled | Stated no other subsidy |
| E | No owned property | Failed (via Exception 3) | Do not own, but rented > 7 yrs (30 yrs). Rented property treated as owned. |
Revision Table: Key Points for Housing Plot Eligibility
| Condition | Check Points | Important Note |
|---|---|---|
| Family Size/Couple | Total members, number of married couples | Minimum members required |
| Income | Total combined monthly income | Exception for pension income applies |
| Criminal Record | Any member with a criminal case | Exception if released from imprisonment |
| Subsidy History | Received any other subsidy | Check if any member benefited |
| Property Ownership | Any member owns residential property | Exception for long-term rented property |
Additional Information: Understanding Eligibility Rules
When evaluating eligibility based on a set of rules and exceptions, it's crucial to follow the process step-by-step. First, check if the applicant meets all the primary conditions. If they fail any condition, check if there is a specific exception mentioned for that failed condition. Carefully interpret the exception to see if it allows the applicant to qualify, refers their case, or confirms their ineligibility. In this housing plot allotment scenario, both the income and property ownership conditions have specific exceptions that modify how they are applied. The interpretation of Exception 3 regarding long-term rental being treated as owned property is key to determining Family B's ineligibility for the housing plot.
Important Questions from Analytical Decision Making
A college council is auditioning students for a cultural festival. They must satisfy the following criteria —
1. Student must know at least one dance form.2. Student must know to play at least one musical instrument.
3. Student must have good acting skills.
Which one of the following will the council definitely select?
A. Z is a Bharat Natyam dancer, a violinist but does not have any acting skills.
B. P plays football, guitar, has acted in road shows and is a classical dancer.
C. J is a contemporary dancer, a great actor and is planning to learn flute.
D. A plays sitar, is a hip-hop dancer and does not have any acting skills.
‘MPQO’ is related to ‘KNSQ’ in a certain way based on the English alphabetical order. In the same way, ‘DGHF’ is related to ‘BEJH’. To which of the following is ‘EINW’ related, following the same logic?
Select the triad in which the numbers are related in the same way as are the numbers of the given triads.
(NOTE: Operations should be performed on the whole numbers, without breaking down the numbers into its constituent digits. E.g., 13 – Operations on 13 such as adding/deleting/multiplying etc. to 13 can be performed. Breaking down 13 into 1 and 3 and then performing mathematical operations on 1 and 3 is not allowed.)
(11, 1, 10)
(13, 7, 90)
In a certain code language, ‘BIRD’ is written as ‘DKTF’ and ‘KITE’ is written as ‘MKVG’. How will ‘EAGLE’ be written in that language?
Family C has a total monthly income of Rs. 26,000 which includes a pension of Rs. 3,000 earned by th widowed gandmother. The married couple has one 3-year-old son. The family has no members who have a criminal case, they do not own a residential property and they have not received any other subsidy. They are living in a rented house for the past 6 years.
