"Distributive Justice is mainly concerned with distribution of honours or wealth". Who said it?
Understanding Distributive Justice
Distributive justice is a key concept in political philosophy, ethics, and economics. It is concerned with the fair allocation of resources, opportunities, wealth, and burdens among members of a society.
Different philosophers have offered various interpretations and theories of what constitutes a just distribution. The question asks which philosopher specifically linked distributive justice to the distribution of honours or wealth.
Identifying the Philosopher
Let's examine the views of the philosophers listed in the options regarding justice:
- Plato: In his work 'The Republic', Plato discusses justice primarily in terms of the proper functioning of society where each part performs its role harmoniously. While concerned with societal structure and individual virtue, his primary definition of justice isn't centered specifically on the distribution of external goods like honours or wealth in the way the question describes.
- Aristotle: In his 'Nicomachean Ethics' and 'Politics', Aristotle distinguishes between different types of justice, including corrective (or rectificatory) justice and distributive justice (dikanomia dianemētikon). Aristotle explicitly defines distributive justice as being concerned with the distribution of honours, wealth, and other divisible goods among the citizens. He argues that this distribution should follow a principle of geometrical proportion (or proportionality) based on merit or contribution, rather than simple arithmetic equality.
- Marx: Karl Marx's theories focus on economic justice within the context of capitalism and the class struggle. While deeply concerned with the distribution of wealth and the abolition of private property, his framework is distinct from Aristotle's classical definition focused on proportional distribution of honours and wealth within a political community based on criteria like merit.
- Gramsci: Antonio Gramsci, a Marxist thinker, focused heavily on concepts like cultural hegemony and the role of intellectuals in achieving social change. His work does not primarily focus on a philosophical definition of distributive justice in the classical sense described in the question.
Based on the analysis of classical philosophical texts, the statement that "Distributive Justice is mainly concerned with distribution of honours or wealth" is a direct reflection of Aristotle's definition of distributive justice.
Conclusion
The philosopher who articulated that distributive justice is mainly concerned with the distribution of honours or wealth is Aristotle.
| Philosopher | Key Idea on Justice / Focus |
|---|---|
| Plato | Justice as societal harmony and proper functioning of roles (Justice in the city and soul) |
| Aristotle | Distributive justice concerned with proportional distribution of honours, wealth, etc., based on merit/contribution. Corrective justice rectifies wrongs. |
| Marx | Economic justice; critique of capitalist distribution; distribution based on need in communism. |
| Gramsci | Cultural hegemony, political power, role of intellectuals in social change (less direct focus on distributive justice definition). |
Revision Table: Philosophers and Justice Concepts
| Philosopher | Relevant Works | Distributive Justice Focus (if applicable) |
|---|---|---|
| Aristotle | Nicomachean Ethics, Politics | Distribution of honours, wealth, and goods based on proportionality (merit). |
| Plato | The Republic | Justice as state harmony and individual virtue; not primarily focused on distribution of goods. |
| Marx | Das Kapital, Critique of the Gotha Programme | Critique of capitalist distribution, vision of communist distribution based on need. |
| Gramsci | Selections from the Prison Notebooks | Focus on power, hegemony, ideology; not a primary focus on classical distributive justice definitions. |
Additional Information: Aristotelian Distributive Justice
Aristotle's view of distributive justice is based on the principle of geometrical proportionality. This means that the share of goods (like honours or wealth) someone receives should be proportional to their merit or contribution to the community. He believed that what constitutes 'merit' could vary depending on the political system (e.g., virtue in an aristocracy, wealth in an oligarchy, free birth in a democracy). Simple arithmetic equality, where everyone gets the same amount regardless of merit, was considered inappropriate for distributive justice by Aristotle. His focus was on fairness in the allocation of divisible goods and offices within the political community.
Important Questions from Polity
In a recent judgement, the Supreme Court of India directed that every protected forest, national park and wildlife sanctuary across the country should have a mandatory eco-sensitive zone (ESZ) of a minimum of
Which one of the following Directive Principles was inserted by the Constitution (42 nd Amendment) Act, 1976?
A common High Court for two or more states can be established by:
Which one among the following is not a Fundamental Right under the Constitution of India?
The Central Vigilance Commission was established on the recommendation of which one of the following Committees?
