All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Consider the following statements:

Assertion (A): Bringing down the influence of the rich and powerful people in making Governmental decision making is the challenge in the concept of 'expansion of democracy'.

Reason (R): People's participation and their control in meaningful, only when influence of the rich is brought down. It results in :Deepening of Democracy".

The correct answer is

(A) is wrong but (R) is correct

Understanding the Assertion and Reason

This question asks us to evaluate two statements, an Assertion (A) and a Reason (R), concerning the expansion of democracy. We need to determine if both statements are correct, if one is correct and the other is wrong, or if both are incorrect, based on democratic principles.

Analyzing Assertion (A): Challenge in Expanding Democracy

Assertion (A) states: "Bringing down the influence of the rich and powerful people in making Governmental decision making is the challenge in the concept of 'expansion of democracy'."

Let's break this down:

  • Expansion of Democracy: This refers to making democratic processes more inclusive and effective, ensuring broader participation and representation.
  • Influence of the Rich and Powerful: In many societies, wealthy individuals or groups can exert significant influence over government decisions, potentially skewing policies in their favor.
  • The Statement's Claim: Assertion (A) identifies the act of "bringing down" this influence as the challenge within the concept of expanding democracy.

While the *presence* of undue influence from the rich is certainly a major obstacle to democratic expansion, framing the *act of reducing* this influence as "the challenge in the concept" might be debatable. The core challenge might be seen as the existence of this disproportionate power itself, or the difficulty in overcoming the systems that allow it. The need to reduce influence is a goal or a requirement for democratic expansion, and the difficulty in achieving this goal constitutes the challenge. However, the phrasing might imply that the concept itself is challenged by the need to reduce influence, rather than the practical implementation being challenged.

Considering the provided answer indicates (A) is wrong, the likely interpretation is that the challenge isn't the process of 'bringing down' the influence, but rather the underlying issue of its existence and the difficulty in counteracting it effectively within the existing structures.

Analyzing Reason (R): People's Participation and Deepening Democracy

Reason (R) states: "People's participation and their control in meaningful, only when influence of the rich is brought down. It results in :Deepening of Democracy".

This statement posits a direct link:

  • Condition for Meaningful Participation: It argues that genuine public participation and effective citizen control over governance are contingent upon reducing the influence wielded by wealthy individuals and powerful groups.
  • Outcome: When this reduction occurs, democracy is said to deepen.

This perspective aligns with core democratic theories. If the political landscape is dominated by the financial power of a few, the voices and participation of ordinary citizens may become marginalized or superficial. When the influence of money in politics is curtailed:

  • Citizens can participate more equally.
  • Their input is more likely to be considered genuinely.
  • Governmental decisions can better reflect the broader public interest, not just the interests of the wealthy.

This enhanced quality of participation and representation leads to a more robust and truly democratic system, hence, a 'deepening of democracy'. Therefore, Reason (R) presents a logically sound and widely accepted argument in political science.

Conclusion: Evaluating the Options

Based on the analysis:

  • Assertion (A) is considered incorrect because the challenge lies more in the *existence* of undue influence and the *difficulty* of reducing it, rather than the mere concept of bringing it down.
  • Reason (R) is considered correct because reducing the influence of the rich is indeed crucial for enabling meaningful public participation and control, which ultimately deepens democracy.

This leads us to conclude that Assertion (A) is wrong, but Reason (R) is correct.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Democracy

  1. Match List I with List II and select the correct answer using the code given below the Lists :
    List I
    (Concept)
    List II
    (Explanation/Aim)
    A. Pluralist democracy1. Power is always exercised by a privileged few
    B. People's democracy2. Highest and harmonious development of individual capacities
    C. Developmental democracy3. Social equality through common ownership of wealth
    D. Elitist democracy4. Capacity of groups to ensure Governmental responsiveness

    Code :
    A B C D
  2. Which of the following are the defining features of liberal democracy?
    1. Constitutional government based on formal, usually legal, rules
    2. Guarantees of civil liberties and individual rights
    3. It invests political authority with potentially unlimited power
    Select the correct answer using the code given below :
  3. Which one among the following is NOT the central feature of Polyarchy ?
  4. "India has a hallowed place in discussions of democracy...... But it has become less tolerant, less secular, less law-abiding, less liberal. And these two trends - democratization and illiberalism- are directly related". Who writes this ?
  5. Who among the following compares the organisations of civil society to a powerful system of 'Fortresses and earthworks' standing behind the state ?
Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App