All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Assertion (A): Due to the experiment of Time, Motion and Fatigue studies, a factory does not remain a factory, it is converted into a laboratory
Reason (R): Management succeeds or fails as human relations in business are intelligently or unintelligently handled

The correct answer is
Both "A" and "R" are correct, but "R" is not the right explanation of "A"

Analyzing Assertion (A): Time, Motion, and Fatigue Studies

Assertion (A) states that experiments like Time, Motion, and Fatigue studies transform a factory into a laboratory. This is related to the principles of Scientific Management, pioneered by Frederick Winslow Taylor. These studies involve:

  • Time Studies: Precisely measuring the time required to perform each task.
  • Motion Studies: Observing and analyzing the movements workers make to eliminate inefficient or unnecessary actions.
  • Fatigue Studies: Investigating the impact of rest pauses and working conditions on worker efficiency.

The goal of these studies is to find the most efficient, standardized way to perform each job. This systematic, analytical, and experimental approach can indeed make the factory environment feel highly controlled and systematic, much like a laboratory where processes are optimized through rigorous observation and data collection. Therefore, Assertion (A) is considered correct in its implication about the nature of work under such studies.

Analyzing Reason (R): Human Relations in Business

Reason (R) posits that management's success is determined by how intelligently human relations are handled within the business. This perspective is central to the Human Relations Movement in management theory, highlighted by the Hawthorne studies. This school of thought emphasizes:

  • The importance of employee morale, satisfaction, and well-being.
  • The impact of social factors and group dynamics on productivity.
  • Effective communication and interpersonal relationships between management and employees.

Modern management widely accepts that focusing on positive human relations is crucial for employee motivation, collaboration, and overall organizational success. Thus, Reason (R) is a correct statement.

Evaluating the Relationship Between Assertion (A) and Reason (R)

The question asks if Reason (R) is the *right explanation* for Assertion (A).

  • Assertion (A) focuses on the *methodology* of scientific management studies and their impact on the factory's operational environment, making it feel like a laboratory due to standardization and efficiency focus.
  • Reason (R) discusses the importance of human factors and relationships for overall management *success*.

While both statements are correct within the context of management principles, the successful handling of human relations (R) does not directly explain *why* time, motion, and fatigue studies create a laboratory-like atmosphere (A). The laboratory feel stems from the scientific and experimental nature of the studies themselves, not primarily from how human relationships are managed. Therefore, Reason (R) is correct, but it does not serve as the right explanation for Assertion (A).

Conclusion

Based on the analysis:

  • Assertion (A) is correct.
  • Reason (R) is correct.
  • Reason (R) does not correctly explain Assertion (A).

This aligns with the option stating that both are correct, but R is not the right explanation of A.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Research Design

  1. Design used in experimental research in which groups are randomly formed and that controls most sources of invalidity is known as

  2. ‘Which of the following are the complete experimental research designs?  

    (A) Factorial design 

    (B) One group after-only design 

    (C) Before-after design with one experiment and two control groups 

    (D) Latin square design 

    (E) One-group before-after design 

    Choose the correct answer from the options given below: 

  3. Identify the stages which may form part of a Research Proposal outline.
    A. Data Fabrication
    B. Methodology
    C. Review of related literature or earlier studies
    D. Specifying objectives
    E. Stating Problem
    Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
  4. Given below are two statements
    Statement I An explanatory correlational design explains the degree of association among two or more. variables
    Statement II In prediction correlational design, the investigator identifies variables that will positively predict an out come
    Choose the correct answer.

  5. Select the option based on the Assertion (A) and Reason (R) :
    Assertion (A): Extraneous Variables can influence the results of a research study.
    Reason (R): Extraneous variables are not controlled by the researcher.
Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App