Question
Assertion (A) : A perfect duty is one which a man not merely ought to perform, but may be justly compelled to perform.
Reason (R) : A perfect duty is one which is not merely recognised by law but enforced.
The correct answer is
3 alone
Perfect Duty Assertion and Reason Analysis
This analysis evaluates the correctness of the Assertion (A) and Reason (R) regarding the concept of a 'perfect duty'.
Assertion (A) Evaluation
Assertion (A) states: "A perfect duty is one which a man not merely ought to perform, but may be justly compelled to perform."
- This definition highlights that perfect duties are mandatory and subject to compulsion, either moral or legal.
- This reflects a standard understanding in ethics and law.
- Conclusion: Assertion (A) is True.
Reason (R) Evaluation
Reason (R) states: "A perfect duty is one which is not merely recognised by law but enforced."
- This reason suggests that legal recognition and enforcement are essential characteristics of a perfect duty.
- However, the core nature of a perfect duty lies in its obligatory and specific character, allowing for compulsion, as stated in Assertion (A).
- While often legally enforced, a duty's perfection is not solely contingent on legal enforcement; moral enforcement or compulsion is also relevant.
- Conclusion: Reason (R) is False.
Final Conclusion
Based on the evaluation, Assertion (A) is true, while Reason (R) is false.
This corresponds to the option indicating that only the assertion is true.
Was this answer helpful?
Important Questions from Jurisprudence
- Which of the following is not a theory of legal personality?
- Match the LIST-I with LIST-II
LIST-I Profounder LIST-II Idea A. Mimansa I. Law and Morals are same B. Smriti II. "Idea of Values" is the foundation C. Post Reformation Europe III. Law derives authority from State and not morals D. Korknov IV. There is distinction between obligatory and recommendatory rules
Choose the correct answer from the options given below: - Which of the following are correct about "legal theory"?
A. It defines Law
B. It analyses legal concepts
C. It deals with mere theory and has no practical importance
D. It highlights salient features of legal system
Choose the correct answer from the options given below. - "True subject matter of ownership in all cases is a right". Who gave this statement?
- Arrange the following in the historical order of development of Natural Law theories (ascending)
A. Union with Divine is end of law
B. Church is the law giver
C. Development of idea of Rationalism
D. Revival of Natural Law
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Need Expert Advice?
