(a) Who among you has the answer?
(b) Whom among you has the answer?
(c) Whom amongst you has the answer?
(d) Who amid you has the answer?
Grammar Focus: Correct Sentence Identification
This question requires identifying the grammatically correct sentence among the given options, focusing on pronoun case (Who vs. Whom) and preposition usage (among vs. amid).
Grammar Rules Explained
- Who vs. Whom: Who is used as the subject of a verb (e.g., Who is there?). Whom is used as the object of a verb or preposition (e.g., To whom did you speak?). To test, substitute 'he/she' (for who) or 'him/her' (for whom). If 'he/she' fits, use 'who'. If 'him/her' fits, use 'whom'.
- Among vs. Amid: Among is typically used when referring to items or people within a group of three or more. Amid usually implies being surrounded by or in the middle of something, often used in contexts of activity or difficulty. "Among you" is standard for referring to a group.
- Among vs. Amongst: Amongst is a variant of among, often considered more formal or archaic. Both are grammatically acceptable, but among is more common in modern usage.
Sentence Analysis
Let's analyze each option based on these rules:
- Option (a): Who among you has the answer? - Uses Who correctly as the subject of the verb 'has'. Uses among appropriately for a group. This is correct.
- Option (b): Whom among you has the answer? - Incorrect. Uses Whom (object case) where the subject case Who is required.
- Option (c): Whom amongst you has the answer? - Incorrect. Uses Whom (object case) instead of the required subject case Who.
- Option (d): Who amid you has the answer? - Incorrect. While Who is correct, amid is not the appropriate preposition for referring to a group in this context; among is preferred.
Conclusion
Based on the analysis, sentence (a) correctly uses the subject pronoun Who and the preposition among.
Important Questions from Sentence Correction
Select the most appropriate option to substitute the underlined segment in the given sentence. If there is no need to substitute it, select No Improvement.
These flowers smell sweetly and are sold at high prices in the market.
Select the most appropriate option to substitute the underlined segment in the given sentence. If there is no need to substitute it, select No Improvement.
While learning to drive, one of the most important things is to know the traffic rules first.
Select the most appropriate option that can substitute the underlined word in the given sentence.
When you give away a secret or an advantage, you reveal a secret or suspension that you should have kept to yourself.
Select the most appropriate option that can substitute the underlined word in the given sentence.
The bacteria in the roots of leguminous plants submerge nitrogen in the soil to compounds.
- Select the most appropriate option that can substitute the underlined word in the given sentence.
The Maldives is one of the few places in the world where ancient pleasure can be derived from doing nothing.
