A statement is followed by two arguments. Decide which of the arguments is are strong with respect to statement. Statement: There should be strict penalty for people using mobile phone while driving. Arguments: I. Yes, it will ensure that the number of accident due to mobile phone usage gets avoided. II. No, it is difficult to implement as people are used to using cell phones anywhere.
Only argument I is strong.
This question asks us to evaluate the strength of two arguments related to a statement about imposing strict penalties for using mobile phones while driving. We need to determine which arguments provide strong support or opposition to the statement.
The statement is: There should be strict penalty for people using mobile phone while driving.
Let's look at the arguments presented:
Argument I claims that strict penalties will lead to avoiding accidents caused by mobile phone usage while driving. This argument focuses on the direct positive outcome of the proposed policy. Strict penalties are generally intended to deter specific behaviors. Using a mobile phone while driving is a major distraction and a significant cause of road accidents. Therefore, a strict penalty would likely discourage this behavior, leading to a reduction in accidents caused by it.
This argument presents a clear and logical consequence of the statement's proposal, directly addressing the public safety aspect. Reducing accidents is a primary goal of traffic regulations. Hence, this argument is strong because it supports the statement based on a desirable and probable outcome related to safety.
Argument II opposes the statement by saying it is difficult to implement because people are used to using cell phones anywhere. This argument points out a practical challenge in enforcing the policy. While it is true that changing public behavior can be difficult and enforcing laws everywhere is challenging, the difficulty of implementation does not necessarily make the argument against the policy strong.
A policy's strength should be judged based on its intended purpose and potential benefits, not solely on the ease of implementation. Many important laws are difficult to enforce, but their value justifies the effort. This argument highlights a practical hurdle but does not weaken the reasoning behind why strict penalties are desirable from a safety perspective. Therefore, this argument is weak as it focuses on feasibility rather than the principle or outcome of the policy itself.
Based on the analysis:
Therefore, only Argument I is strong.
Considering the evaluation of both arguments, only Argument I is strong with respect to the statement.
| Argument | Main Point | Strength Evaluation | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|---|
| I | Strict penalty reduces accidents from mobile phone usage. | Strong | Directly links penalty to positive safety outcome (accident reduction). Penalties deter unsafe behavior. |
| II | Difficult to implement due to people's habits. | Weak | Focuses on implementation difficulty, not the principle or potential benefit of the policy. Feasibility challenges don't negate policy value. |
In logical reasoning, analyzing statements and arguments involves assessing whether the arguments strongly support or oppose the given statement. A strong argument is relevant to the statement and provides a compelling reason to accept or reject it based on facts, principles, or likely consequences. A weak argument may be irrelevant, based on faulty logic, or focus on minor points or difficulties that do not undermine the core assertion of the statement.
When evaluating arguments, consider the following:
Arguments about implementation difficulty are often considered weak if the policy's potential benefits are significant, as they address practicality rather than the fundamental merit of the proposal.
Each question given below consists of a statement, followed by two arguments numbered I and II. You have to decide which of the arguments is a 'strong' argument and which is a 'weak' argument.
Give answer:
(A) If only argument I is strong
(B) If only argument II is strong
(C) If either I or II is strong
(D) If neither I nor II is strong and
(E) If both I and II are strong.
Statement:
Should the government be involved in internet censorship?
Arguments:
I. Yes, if more content is closely monitored by the government, it could cut down on the mass amounts of fraudulent information including false advertising.
II. No, government should concentrate on other sensitive issues.
The question given below consists of a statement, followed by two arguments numbered 1 and 2. You have to decide which of the arguments is a 'strong' argument and which is a 'weak' argument.
Give answer:
(A) If only argument1 is strong
(B) If only argument 2 is strong
(C) If either 1 or 2 is strong
(D) If neither 1 nor 2 is strong and
(E) If both 1 and 2 are strong.
Statement:
Should there be a ban on smoking in public places?
Argument:
1. Yes, this will decrease the possibility of fire disasters.
2. No, they are not effective.
Each question given below consists of a statement, followed by two arguments numbered I and II. You have to decide which of the arguments is a 'strong' argument and which is a 'weak' argument.
Give answer:
(A) If only argument I is strong
(B) If only argument II is strong
(C) If either I or II is strong
(D) If neither I nor II is strong and
(E) If both I and II are strong.
Statement:
Should kids be allowed to drink coffee?
Arguments:
I. Yes, kids might suffer from stomach problems that occur from a decreased appetite due to the stimulating nature of caffeine.
II. No, drinking coffee at night causes sleep issues.